GemNet: Menu-Based, Strategy-Proof Multi-Bidder Auctions Through Deep Learning

Yanchen Jiang,David C. Parkes,Tonghan Wang
2024-10-28
Abstract:Automated mechanism design (AMD) uses computational methods for mechanism design. Differentiable economics is a form of AMD that uses deep learning to learn mechanism designs and has enabled strong progress in AMD in recent years. Nevertheless, a major open problem has been to learn multi-bidder, general, and fully strategy-proof (SP) auctions. We introduce GEneral Menu-based NETwork (GemNet), which significantly extends the menu-based approach of the single-bidder RochetNet (Dütting et al., 2024) to the multi-bidder setting. The challenge in achieving SP is to learn bidder-independent menus that are feasible, so that the optimal menu choices for each bidder do not over-allocate items when taken together (we call this menu compatibility). GemNet penalizes the failure of menu compatibility during training, and transforms learned menus after training through price changes, by considering a set of discretized bidder values and reasoning about Lipschitz smoothness to guarantee menu compatibility on the entire value space. This approach is general, leaving trained menus that already satisfy menu compatibility undisturbed and reducing to RochetNet for a single bidder. Mixed-integer linear programs are used for menu transforms, and through a number of optimizations enabled by deep learning, including adaptive grids and methods to skip menu elements, we scale to large auction design problems. GemNet learns auctions with better revenue than affine maximization methods, achieves exact SP whereas previous general multi-bidder methods are approximately SP, and offers greatly enhanced interpretability.
Computer Science and Game Theory,Artificial Intelligence,Machine Learning
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to design an auction mechanism that can handle multiple bidders, is general, and is fully strategy - proof (SP). Specifically, the paper aims to achieve this goal through deep - learning methods, especially to ensure the strategy - proofness (SP) of the auction mechanism in a multi - bidder environment, while guaranteeing its expressiveness and multi - bidder support. The following are the main problems and challenges of the paper: 1. **Strategy - proofness in a multi - bidder environment**: Traditional single - bidder auction mechanisms (such as RochetNet) have been able to handle strategy - proofness well, but in a multi - bidder environment, ensuring that each bidder's menu selection does not lead to over - allocation of items (i.e., menu compatibility) is a huge challenge. 2. **Expressiveness and multi - bidder support**: Existing methods can either only handle single bidders or cannot fully guarantee strategy - proofness in a multi - bidder environment. Therefore, a new method is needed that can handle multiple bidders and maintain strong expressiveness, so as to design an optimal auction mechanism. 3. **Optimizing revenue and ensuring strategy - proofness**: In addition to ensuring strategy - proofness, it is also necessary to optimize the revenue of the auction, so that the designed auction mechanism is not only fair but also can bring maximum benefits to the auctioneer. ### Specific contributions of the paper To address the above challenges, the paper proposes GEneral Menu - based NETwork (GEMNET), a menu - based deep - learning method with the following characteristics: - **Menu compatibility**: GEMNET ensures that the menu selections of multiple bidders do not lead to over - allocation of items by introducing the concept of "menu compatibility". Specifically, it introduces an incompatible loss function during the training process and ensures menu compatibility over the entire range of values by adjusting menu prices after training. - **Strategy - proofness**: GEMNET ensures that the finally designed auction mechanism is fully strategy - proof through a series of optimization techniques, including mixed - integer linear programming (MILP) and Lipschitz smoothness arguments. - **Expressiveness and multi - bidder support**: GEMNET can learn complex auction mechanisms in a multi - bidder environment while maintaining strong expressiveness, enabling it to handle various types of auction problems. ### Experimental results The experimental results show that GEMNET significantly outperforms existing methods in a multi - bidder environment, especially in terms of revenue optimization and strategy - proofness. In addition, GEMNET can also recover known theoretical optimal solutions, further verifying its effectiveness and superiority. In conclusion, through the introduction of GEMNET, this paper has successfully solved the design problem of strategy - proof auction mechanisms in a multi - bidder environment, bringing important progress to the field of automated mechanism design.