The two-spin enigma: from the helium atom to quantum ontology

Philippe Grangier,Alexia Auffeves,Nayla Farouki,Mathias Van Den Bossche,Olivier Ezratty
2024-08-28
Abstract:The purpose of this article is to provide a novel approach and justification of the idea that classical physics and quantum physics can neither function nor even be conceived one without the other - in line with ideas attributed to e.g. Niels Bohr or Lev Landau. Though this point of view may go against current common wisdom, we will show that it perfectly fits with empirical evidence, and can be maintained without giving up physical realism. In order to place our arguments in a convenient historical perspective, we will proceed as if we were following the path of a police investigation, about the demise, or vanishing, of some valuable properties of the two electrons in the helium atom. We will start from experimentally based evidence in order to analyse and explain physical facts, moving cautiously from a classical to a quantum description, without mixing them up. The overall picture will be that the physical properties of microscopic systems are quantized, as initially shown by Planck and Einstein, and they are also contextual, i.e. that they can be given a physical sense only by embedding a microscopic system within a macroscopic measurement context.
History and Philosophy of Physics,Quantum Physics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper attempts to address the relationship and interdependence between classical physics and quantum physics. Specifically: 1. **Theoretical Background**: The paper explores whether classical physics and quantum physics can exist or operate independently and proposes a new perspective that they cannot exist independently but are interdependent. 2. **The Helium Atom Puzzle**: By analyzing the states of the two electrons in a helium atom, the paper reveals some fundamental issues in quantum mechanics, particularly how to describe their wave functions and the behavior of these states in different measurement contexts when dealing with two spin-1/2 particles. 3. **Quantum Entanglement and Uncertainty**: The paper discusses how to interpret the value of a single electron's spin component when two electrons are in an entangled state (such as |s⟩ or |r⟩). Especially in the case of long distances, it examines how this entangled state affects the measurement results of each electron and explores the nature of quantum entanglement. 4. **Bell's Inequality and Local Hidden Variables**: By introducing the results of Bell's inequality experiments, the paper further discusses the issue of predictive incompleteness in quantum mechanics, i.e., the inability to fully predict all possible events solely based on the quantum state vector |ψ⟩, and the necessity to combine specific measurement contexts to provide a probability distribution. Overall, the paper aims to explore the fundamental concepts of quantum mechanics and its challenges in practical applications by analyzing the relationship between classical physics and quantum physics, and attempts to clarify the issues of reality and objectivity in quantum phenomena.