Abstract:We investigate the properties of the photon Bose-Einstein condensate in the limit of small mode spacing. Alongside the well-known threshold of the phase transition at large mode spacings, we find an emergence of a second threshold for sufficiently small mode spacings, defining the crossover to a fully condensed state. Furthermore, we present our findings for the mode occupations in the precondensate or supercooling region towards the continuum limit.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper explores the properties of photon Bose - Einstein condensation (PBEC) in the continuous limit. Specifically, the researchers focus on the behavioral characteristics of photon Bose - Einstein condensation when the mode spacing is small. The main contribution of the paper is the discovery that under the condition of small mode spacing, in addition to the known phase - transition threshold for large mode spacing, there exists a second threshold, which marks the transition of the system from a partially condensed state to a fully condensed state.
### Main Problems and Findings
1. **Problem Background**:
- Bose - Einstein condensation (BEC) is a quantum phenomenon. When the temperature is below a certain critical value, a large number of particles will occupy the lowest energy state.
- For photon BEC, the phase transition is usually achieved by increasing the number of photons in the cavity.
- In a two - dimensional system, condensation usually does not occur due to the thermodynamic limit.
2. **Research Motivation**:
- The researchers hope to understand whether the properties of photon BEC will change under the condition of small mode spacing.
- In particular, in the continuous limit, that is, when the mode spacing is very small, how the phase - transition behavior of the system is.
3. **Main Findings**:
- Two critical thresholds are discovered:
- The first threshold (\(\Gamma_{\text{th1}}^{\uparrow}\)): Similar to the threshold under the condition of large mode spacing, it is mainly determined by the spontaneous emission rate \(\Gamma_{\downarrow}\) of molecules.
- The second threshold (\(\Gamma_{\text{th2}}^{\uparrow}\)): Appears under the condition of small mode spacing and is mainly determined by the cavity decay rate \(\kappa\).
- Between these two thresholds, the system is in the "pre - condensation" or "super - cooled" region. At this time, the occupation number of the ground - state mode gradually increases but has not yet reached the fully condensed state.
- As the mode spacing decreases, the second threshold gradually increases and finally tends to infinity, resulting in that in a free 2D photon gas, the separation of the ground - state mode requires an infinite pumping rate.
### Mathematical Model and Method
1. **Model Description**:
- The system consists of a planar cavity, and the control parameter is the transverse mode spacing \(\Delta k_{\parallel}\).
- The frequency \(\omega(j_x, j_y, \Delta k_{\parallel})\) of the cavity mode is given by the following formula:
\[
\omega(j_x, j_y, \Delta k_{\parallel}) = c\epsilon^{- 1/2}\sqrt{\left(\frac{j_z\pi}{L_z}\right)^2+(j_x^2 + j_y^2)(\Delta k_{\parallel})^2}
\]
- Where \(c\) is the speed of light, \(\epsilon\) is the relative permittivity of the cavity medium, \(j_z\) is the longitudinal mode number, \(L_z\) is the cavity length, \(j_x\) and \(j_y\) are the transverse mode numbers respectively, \(\Delta k_{\parallel}=\Delta k_x=\Delta k_y = \frac{\pi}{L}\), and \(L\) is the length of the cavity mirror in the \(x\) and \(y\) directions.
2. **Dynamics Equation**:
- The rate equation of the photon number \(n_i\) is derived through the master equation:
\[
\dot{n}_i(\Gamma^{\uparrow})=-\kappa n_i+\frac{M\epsilon_i\Gamma_{\text{tot}}^{\uparrow}(n_i + 1)-\alpha_i\Gamma_{\text{tot}}^{\downarrow}
\]