Identification of hot gas around low-mass protostars

Merel L.R. van 't Hoff,Edwin A. Bergin,Penelope Riley,Sanil Mittal,Jes K. Jørgensen,John J. Tobin

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3847/1538-4357/ad4be4

2024-05-24

Abstract:The low carbon content of Earth and primitive meteorites compared to the Sun and interstellar grains suggests that carbon-rich grains were destroyed in the inner few astronomical units of the young solar system. A promising mechanism to selectively destroy carbonaceous grains is thermal sublimation within the soot line at $\gtrsim$ 300 K. To address whether such hot conditions are common amongst low-mass protostars, we observe CH$_3$CN transitions at 1, 2 and 3 mm with the NOrthern Extended Millimeter Array (NOEMA) toward seven low-mass and one intermediate-mass protostar ($L_{\rm{bol}} \sim2-300 L_\odot$), as CH$_3$CN is an excellent temperature tracer. We find $>$ 300 K gas toward all sources, indicating that hot gas may be prevalent. Moreover, the excitation temperature for CH$_3$OH obtained with the same observations is always lower ($\sim$135-250 K), suggesting that CH$_3$CN and CH$_3$OH have a different spatial distribution. A comparison of the column densities at 1 and 3 mm shows a stronger increase at 3 mm for CH$_3$CN than for CH$_3$OH. Since the dust opacity is lower at longer wavelengths, this indicates that CH$_3$CN is enhanced in the hot gas compared to CH$_3$OH. If this CH$_3$CN enhancement is the result of carbon-grain sublimation, these results suggests that Earth's initial formation conditions may not be rare.

Astrophysics of Galaxies

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper primarily aims to address the following issues:

### Research Background and Objectives

- **Carbon Content Issue**: The carbon content in the Earth and primitive meteorites is significantly lower compared to the Sun and interstellar dust, suggesting that in the early solar system, carbon-rich particles might have been destroyed or evaporated within a few astronomical units from the Sun.
- **Carbon Particle Evaporation Mechanism**: One possible mechanism is the selective destruction of carbon-rich particles through thermal evaporation within the so-called "soot line," which occurs at temperatures exceeding approximately 300K.
- **Research Objective**: To investigate whether such high-temperature conditions are common in low-mass protostars, the authors observed multiple lines of methyl cyanide (CH₃CN) to search for gas with temperatures above 300K.

### Observation Methods and Samples

- **Observation Targets**: Eight low-mass protostars and one intermediate-mass protostar were selected as observation samples.
- **Observation Means**: Using the NOrthern Extended Millimeter Array (NOEMA) telescope, multiple rotational transitions of CH₃CN and CH₃OH molecules around these protostars were observed in the 1mm, 2mm, and 3mm bands.
- **Analysis Methods**: The excitation temperature of the molecules was determined through rotational diagram analysis of the observed lines, considering the effects of beam dilution and optical thickness.

### Main Findings

- **Presence of High-Temperature Gas**: All observed targets showed the presence of gas with temperatures greater than 300K, indicating that high-temperature gas might be common around low-mass protostars.
- **Spatial Distribution of Different Molecules**: The excitation temperature of CH₃CN is always higher than that of CH₃OH, suggesting that these two molecules have different spatial distributions.
- **Beam Dilution Effect**: Comparison of the column densities of these two molecules in the 1mm and 3mm bands shows that the increase of CH₃CN at longer wavelengths is more pronounced than that of CH₃OH, implying a relatively higher abundance of CH₃CN in high-temperature regions.
- **Understanding Earth's Formation Conditions**: If this CH₃CN enhancement is caused by the evaporation of carbon particles, then the initial formation conditions of the Earth might not be an uncommon phenomenon.

In summary, this study reveals the widespread presence of high-temperature gas environments around low-mass protostars through the spectral characteristics of methyl cyanide and methanol molecules, and discusses the importance of such environments for understanding the early formation conditions of the Earth.