Testing grain surface chemistry : a survey of deuterated formaldehyde and methanol in low-mass Class 0 protostars

B. Parise,C. Ceccarelli,A.G.G.M. Tielens,A. Castets,E. Caux,B. Lefloch,S. Maret
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361%3A20054476
2006-03-07
Abstract:Context : Despite the low cosmic abundance of deuterium (D/H ~ 1e-5), large degrees of deuterium fractionation in molecules are observed in star forming regions with enhancements that can reach 13 orders of magnitude, which current models have difficulties to account for. Aims : Multi-isotopologue observations are a very powerful constraint for chemical models. The aim of our observations is to understand the processes forming the observed large abundances of methanol and formaldehyde in low-mass protostellar envelopes (gas-phase processes ? chemistry on the grain surfaces ?) and better constrain the chemical models. Methods : Using the IRAM 30m single-dish telescope, we observed deuterated formaldehyde (HDCO and D2CO) and methanol (CH2DOH, CH3OD, and CHD2OH) towards a sample of seven low-mass class 0 protostars. Using population diagrams, we then derive the fractionation ratios of these species (abundance ratio between the deuterated molecule and its main isotopologue) and compare them to the predictions of grain chemistry models. Results : These protostars show a similar level of deuteration as in IRAS16293-2422, where doubly-deuterated methanol -- and even triply-deuterated methanol -- were first detected. Our observations point to the formation of methanol on the grain surfaces, while formaldehyde formation cannot be fully pined down. While none of the scenarii can be excluded (gas-phase or grain chemistry formation), they both seem to require abstraction reactions to reproduce the observed fractionations.
Astrophysics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### Problems the paper attempts to solve This paper aims to explore and explain the formation mechanisms of the high abundances of methanol and formaldehyde observed in low - mass Class 0 protostars. Specifically, the research objectives include: 1. **Understanding the deuteration process**: Although the abundance of deuterium (D) in the universe is very low (D/H ~ \(10^{-5}\)), a high degree of molecular deuteration has been observed in star - forming regions, and in some cases, the degree of deuteration can be enhanced by 13 orders of magnitude. Current models have difficulty explaining this high degree of deuteration. 2. **Distinguishing between gas - phase and ice - surface chemical processes**: Use multi - isotope observations to distinguish the roles of gas - phase chemical reactions and ice - surface chemical reactions in the formation of these high - abundance methanol and formaldehyde. The specific goal is to determine whether these molecules are mainly formed on the ice - surface or generated through gas - phase processes. 3. **Constraining chemical models**: Through observations of deuterated formaldehyde (HDCO and D₂CO) and methanol (CH₂DOH, CH₃OD and CHD₂OH), derive the deuteration ratios of these species and compare them with the predictions of ice - surface chemical models to better constrain existing chemical models. 4. **Verifying universality**: By observing multiple samples of low - mass Class 0 protostars, verify whether the high - deuteration phenomenon first discovered in IRAS16293−2422 is universal, thereby confirming whether this is a common phenomenon in the protostellar environment. ### Research background In the past few years, observations of low - mass protostars have revealed unexpectedly high abundances of deuterated molecules, especially doubly - deuterated molecules. For example, a very large amount of doubly - deuterated formaldehyde (D₂CO/H₂CO ~ 10%) has been found in the low - mass protostar IRAS16293−2422. This finding suggests that high deuteration may be formed during the cold and dense pre - collapse stage of low - mass protostars. In addition, methanol is considered to be an ice - surface product because gas - phase processes are not sufficient to explain the large abundances observed in star - forming regions. Through this research, the author hopes to further verify these findings and provide new insights into understanding the chemical evolution in the star - formation process.