Play Across Boundaries: Exploring Cross-Cultural Maldaimonic Game Experiences

Katie Seaborn,Satoru Iseya,Shun Hidaka,Sota Kobuki,Shruti Chandra

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1145/3613904.3642273

2024-05-14

Abstract:Maldaimonic game experiences occur when people engage in personally fulfilling play through egocentric, destructive, and/or exploitative acts. Initial qualitative work verified this orientation and experiential construct for English-speaking Westerners. In this comparative mixed methods study, we explored whether and how maldaimonic game experiences and orientations play out in Japan, an Eastern gaming capital that may have cultural values incongruous with the Western philosophical basis underlying maldaimonia. We present findings anchored to the initial frameworks on maldaimonia in game experiences that show little divergence between the Japanese and US cohorts. We also extend the qualitative findings with quantitative measures on affect, player experience, and the related constructs of hedonia and eudaimonia. We confirm this novel construct for Japan and set the stage for scale development.

Human-Computer Interaction,Computers and Society

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper discusses the negative self-fulfilling experiences in games in a cross-cultural context, known as maldaimonic game experiences. These experiences involve personal satisfaction through self-centered, destructive, or exploitative behaviors in games. Preliminary research has validated this concept among English-speaking users in the United States, but its manifestation in different cultures remains insufficiently studied.

The researchers conducted an online survey with Japanese players using a comparative approach to explore whether maldaimonic game experiences exist in Japan and to compare them with the experiences of American players. They found that maldaimonic game experiences among Japanese players were similar to those among American players, albeit with some differences. The study expanded on qualitative findings by measuring emotions, player experiences, and related constructs such as hedonia and eudaimonia quantitatively.

The main research question of the paper is whether maldaimonic game UX is a cross-cultural phenomenon. Specifically, the researchers wanted to understand whether Japanese players have similar maldaimonic game experiences to American players and whether maldaimonia is associated with factors such as hedonia, eudaimonia, player experience, and emotions. The results showed that the experiences of Japanese players were largely consistent with those of American players, indicating the cross-cultural universality of maldaimonic game UX.

Furthermore, the paper suggests that the concept of maldaimonia may have originated from Western culture but is still applicable in other cultural contexts, especially in Japan as a major gaming country. This lays a foundation for further theorizing and measuring maldaimonic game UX in diverse cultural environments in the future.