Mind Games: Affective Ludo(bio)technologies of Fear
Laurent Milesi
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/13534645.2023.2184950
2022-01-01
Parallax
Abstract:Click to increase image sizeClick to decrease image size Disclosure StatementNo potential conflict of interest was reported by the author(s).Additional informationNotes on contributorsLaurent MilesiLaurent Milesi is Tenured Professor of English at Shanghai Jiao Tong University and Honorary Senior Research Fellow at Cardiff University. He has written extensively on James Joyce and modernism, 20th-century (American) poetry, postmodernism and poststructuralism (especially on Jacques Derrida and Hélène Cixous, several of whose works he has translated) and, increasingly, game studies. He has edited James Joyce and the Difference of Language (Cambridge University Press, 2003) and, with Christopher John Müller and Aidan Tynan, Credo Credit Crisis: Speculations on Faith and Money (Rowman & Littlefield International, 2017). He serves as joint Editor-in-Chief for the international journal Word and Text – A Journal of Literary Studies and Linguistics. Email: milesi@sjtu.edu.cnNotes1 Aristotle, Poetics, especially 10, 17, 20–21; Rhetoric, 66 (II 5, 1381a).2 I am using the term generically throughout, regardless of differences in types – such as propositional, experiential, reactive in Davis, “The Varieties of Fear” – and intensity, including with near-synonyms like fright, dread, terror, anxiety and anguish, etc. or even (object-based) phobia, specific instances of which are examined infra.3 A similar point could be made about notorious thrillers in cinema, such as the classic Cape Fear (dir. J. Lee Thompson, 1962) and its remake (dir. Martin Scorsese, 1991). Alongside Stephen King’s horror novel It (1986), Fear of Clowns and its sequel (dir. Kevin Kangas, 2004, 2007) may have inspired one of the images shown to Josh during the ‘working-through’ session with ‘the analyst’ Dr. Hill ‘to understand the root of [his] anxiety’ in Until Dawn (Supermassive Games, 2015), then the horror-themed roller coaster of Until Dawn: Rush of Blood (2016).4 The first book-length account of the genesis and evolution of the genre as well as of the debates surrounding it is Francisco’s Walking Simulators.5 See, for instance, Therrien, “Games of Fear,” especially 35 ff., which refers to Bernard Perron’s research project on interactive cinema and the Ludiciné online database.6 Horror videogames’ indebtedness to H. P. Lovecraft’s Cthulhu Mythos universe can be traced, for its major prototype, to the original Alone in the Dark (Infogrames, 1992), followed by numerous Call of Cthulhu spin-offs listed in the Wikipedia article on “Cthulhu Mythos in Popular Culture”. Specific critical studies include Krzywinska, “Reanimating Lovecraft,” and Lessard, “Lovecraft.” The HPL game engine, developed by Frictional Games, was named after him.7 Among game non-specific studies which have explored the prevalence of Gothic elements in videogames, see Taylor, “Gothic Bloodlines;” Kirkland, “Survival Horrality” and Videogames and the Gothic; Krzywinska, “Digital Games and the American Gothic,” “Gamification of Gothic” and “The Gamification of Gothic Coordinates in Videogames.”8 In The World of Scary Video Games, 131–246, Perron retraces the wider history of the videoludic horror genre, from the more scattered titles of the 1980s, through the rise of the survival horror proper (1992–2005), to the fight or flight opposition (2006–2016), and beyond. See also Therrien, “Games of Fear;” Grip, “Making Games Classics.”9 Darkworks, Alone in the Dark: The New Nightmare (Paris: Infogrames, 2001). For a study of the evolution of the staging of fear in the franchise, see Roux-Girard, “Plunged Alone into Darkness.”10 Fear and all forms of insanity are frequently paired as horror game tropes; see, for instance, the Wikipedia listings for “Video Games Set in Psychiatric Hospitals.” Lane’s “The Art of Video Game Madness” is one among countless round-ups on the topic, which also highlights developers’ increasing awareness of the necessity to portray mental disorders in more nuanced, sympathetic ways.11 Even a seemingly innocuous, non-threatening game like The Sims 2 (Maxis Redwood Shores, 2004) incorporates an ‘Aspiration Bar’ which, if depleted, will lead the player to a mental breakdown and hallucinations in the form of a therapist attempting to recalibrate their mental state. (The franchise’s 2009 third instalment allows the player to choose an ‘Insane’ trait for their Sim among many new character customisation options.) For a selection of mainstream games using a sanity gauge, see, for instance, “Sanity Meter Games.” Among those cited is Darkest Dungeon (Red Hook Studios, 2016), in which the avatar’s prolonged overexposure to horror eventually brings in Interface Screw and, at one point, suicide.12 To the point of fear not being the game’s high point for Perron in The World of Scary Video Games, 120–121. For a more detailed analysis of the whole series, focusing on feminist and postcolonial interpretations of fear, (Alma-related) abjection and horror, see Nae, Horror Video Games as Procedural Narratives, 167–192, as well as, for the latter themes, Spittle, “‘Did This Game Scare You?…’.”13 See Sabbagh, “Don’t Fear the Yurei.”14 Such a process is even taken literally in a later, though more conventional game like The Evil Within (Tango Gameworks, 2014), a brutal spookfest which has the gamer play as a police detective trapped inside the empty asylum of a killer’s distorted mind, travelling through twisted environments and fighting terrifying enemies all based on the killer’s memories and emotions.15 The terrifying unknowability of darkness is made apparent by contrasting gameplay in Normal Mode vs. Daytime Mode in the cult game Slender: The Eight Pages (Parsec Productions, 2012), in which the gamer roams a disorienting, uniform forest scenery trying to avoid eye contact with Slender Man, whose anguishing unpredictability resides in its random teleportation game mechanics. For an analysis of its effective, minimalist gameplay, see Dudek, “A Sense of Fear and Anxiety…”16 So much so that Amnesia went on to have an impact even on the time-honoured Resident Evil franchise – whose initial 1996 title first earned the appellation ‘survival game’ before its retroactive application to earlier titles and whose first two games had provided inspiration for The Dark Descent – with Resident Evil 7: Biohazard (Capcom, 2017) going first-person and emphasising psychological horror. See Paget, “How Resident Evil Became the ‘Guiding Light’ for SOMA and Amnesia.”17 For an outline of some possible antecedents to the Amnesia game strand, including 3D Monster Maze (Malcolm Evans, 1981), developed for the Sinclair ZX81 platform, and little-known Korean survival-horror White Day: A Labyrinth Named School (Sonnori, 2001), see Lemke, “Can't Look Away.”18 This common childhood anxiety before going to bed is the theme of the recently released indie game Lights Off! (TheDollarGameStore, 2022).19 See Thon, “Playing with Fear.”20 For this, see also “The Science of Fear” in the Bonus Contents section of the Until Dawn DVD, also available at https://www.youtube.com/watch?v = C-Y1ZP3kPX0&list = PLg5k9t7fx-vX3xyXp-xR2dkMpnTKabSGa&index = 4, about testing the effectiveness of fear situations.21 See the interviews with Thomas Grip, items 1, 2 and 4 in the Bibliography.22 In Grip’s words, to prevent lurking horror from becoming ‘a familiar gameplay object’ (quoted in Thomsen, “Revival Horror”). A similar point is made by Bauman, who then connects fear to darkness: ‘“Fear” is the name we give to our uncertainty: to our ignorance of the threat and of what is to be done’ (Liquid Fear, 2). See also Lovecraft, Supernatural Horror in Literature, for whom “[t]he oldest and strongest emotion of mankind is fear, and the oldest and strongest kind of fear is fear of the unknown.” (12)23 It is worth noting that in “The Psychology of Fear…” Adam Price contrasts the usual reliance on more direct ‘shock horror’ in Western horror games with the more subtle psychological atmosphere and tension in their Eastern counterparts.24 Wilde, The Picture of Dorian Gray, 9; the aphoristic words are uttered by Basil Hallward, an artist infatuated with Dorian's beauty.25 Bloober Team, Layers of Fear 2 (Lexington, KY: Gun Media, NA Publishing, 2019), from which subsequent quotations in this section are derived, and Layers of Fear (Austin, TX: Aspyr, 2016).26 For an excellent analysis of the layering of meanings, see Wood, “How Layers of Fear 2 Evokes…”27 For some of the filmic allusions in the game, see Dingman, “Layers of Fear 2 Review.”28 See Milesi, “Posthumanism and Digital Gaming,” which also lists earlier studies.29 Boulter, Parables of the Posthuman, 1–2.30 Ibid., 2.31 The Oxford English Dictionary traces the first use of the word to a 1970 article published in The Journal of Transpersonal Psychology, coincidentally the year when Alvin Toffler popularised the notion of ‘cyborg’, in use for a decade, by suggesting that these ‘[a]dvanced fusions of man and machine […] are closer than most people suspect.’ (Future Shock, 209, before the section “The Cyborgs among Us,” 209–215) For a good accessible introduction to the development of biofeedback and range of applications, including in videogame treatment, see West, Biofeedback.32 Retrieved from the product website at https://www.somaticvision.com/products/aliveclinical.33 For the latter, see Bouchard et al., “Using Biofeedback while Immersed in a Stressful Videogame…” See also Elliott et al., “More than Just a Game?” and Miller, “How Video Games Are Saving Those Who Served” for how (VR-related) game technologies more generally are used as therapy for veterans, especially suffering from PTSD.34 See trailers at https://www.youtube.com/watch?v = Ez5p3LXLYjw and https://www.youtube.com/watch?v = buNaErarLts. Analyses include Schoneveld et al., “A Neurofeedback Video Game (Mindlight)…;” Wijnhoven et al., “The Effect of the Video Game Mindlight…”35 For a technical presentation, see the trailer at https://www.youtube.com/watch?v = 7T_iQsOseAg. Research papers on this particular game are listed on the Deep VR website at https://www.exploredeep.com/#science. See also Feathers, “Videogame Technology…”36 For another all-round discussion of the affective input in biofeedback games, using the ‘affective horror game’ Vanish (3DrunkMen, 2013) as a test case, see Nacke et al., “Games of the Heart and Mind.”37 For more technical presentations, see Reynolds, “Quit Playing Games with My Heart” and “Biofeedback and Gaming.”38 See also Kuchera, “Nevermind Is a Panic Attack…”39 Quotations in this paragraph and below are from Flying Mollusk’s Nevermind (Los Angeles: Flying Mollusk, 2015).40 Reynolds, “Quit Playing Games with My Heart.”41 As defined by Hofstadter in his epoch-making Gödel, Escher, Bach, 127.42 See https://www.youtube.com/watch?v = 6cx9dvXvhWk.43 For the use of fear games as exposure therapy, see, for instance, Hannah, “Scary Video Games…”, and for the more general therapeutic function of video games, see Bean, Working with Video Gamers and Games in Therapy.44 See Gilgenbach’s Kickstarter webpage and also VanOrd’s feature on GameSpot.45 Derrida, “Faith and Knowledge…,” 81.46 Derrida, “The Rhetoric of Drugs,” 244–245.