A View of How Language Models Will Transform Law

Frank Fagan

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2405.07826

2024-05-13

Abstract:While most commentators have focused exclusively on how LLMs will transform day-to-day law practice, a substantial structural change could be afoot within the legal sector as a whole. Large increases in productivity and attendant cost savings could encourage law firms and corporate legal departments to develop large language models in-house. A ten percent increase in attorney productivity would encourage an average sized 'Big Law' firm to reduce its associate headcount by 300 to 400 lawyers. This represents cost savings of 60 to 120 million dollars - more than enough to pay for the development of a specialized LLM. Eventually, LLMs will push lawyers into highly specialized and nuanced roles. After fully mature LLMs arrive, the lawyer will continue to play a central role in legal practice, but only in non-routine legal tasks. These tasks will primarily involve value judgments, such as the development of precedent or its reversal, or the allocation of property and other scarce resources. This new mix of lawyer-machine labor, where machines primarily carry out routine legal tasks, and lawyers handle the non-routine, will give rise to a growing demand for lawyers who can exercise good judgment and empathize with the winners and losers of social change. Overall, the Article suggests a possible future where there are fewer lawyers and greater consolidation of the legal sector.

Computers and Society

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: how will large language models (LLMs) change legal practice and the legal service industry. Specifically, the paper explores the following aspects:

1. **Emergence of new legal work**:
- The introduction of LLMs will trigger new legal issues regarding data property rights, language model outputs, and prompts designed by lawyers.
- Lawyers need to assist judges in dealing with new types of torts brought about by the lightly - supervised use of large language models, such as legal negligence.

2. **Improvement of lawyer productivity**:
- As generative AI technology matures and relevant regulations become clear, future lawyers can use language models to save time and costs, thereby improving work efficiency.
- This increase in efficiency may lead law firms to reduce the number of junior lawyers in order to save costs.

3. **Structural changes in the legal industry**:
- Due to the significant increase in productivity and the resulting cost savings, law firms and corporate legal departments may develop in - house large language models.
- Large law firms may enhance client stickiness by having proprietary language models, thus changing the power balance between partners and the law firm.

4. **Transformation of the lawyer's role**:
- When LLMs are fully mature, lawyers will continue to play a central role in non - routine legal tasks, such as tasks involving value judgments, such as the establishment or overturning of precedents, or resource allocation.
- The new human - machine collaboration model will increase the demand for lawyers who can make good judgments and empathize with the winners and losers of social change.

5. **Competition in data quality and processing capacity**:
- The advantages of using LLMs depend on the cost structure of data quality and processing capacity. If capital investment can improve performance, then law firms can distinguish themselves through investment in generative AI.
- Data access and processing capacity will become key factors in the competition in the legal industry.

Overall, this paper explores how LLMs will change legal practice in the future and puts forward hypotheses regarding structural changes in the legal industry, the transformation of the lawyer's role, and the impact of data and technology investments.