Large Language Models in Law: A Survey

Jinqi Lai,Wensheng Gan,Jiayang Wu,Zhenlian Qi,Philip S. Yu
2023-11-26
Abstract:The advent of artificial intelligence (AI) has significantly impacted the traditional judicial industry. Moreover, recently, with the development of AI-generated content (AIGC), AI and law have found applications in various domains, including image recognition, automatic text generation, and interactive chat. With the rapid emergence and growing popularity of large models, it is evident that AI will drive transformation in the traditional judicial industry. However, the application of legal large language models (LLMs) is still in its nascent stage. Several challenges need to be addressed. In this paper, we aim to provide a comprehensive survey of legal LLMs. We not only conduct an extensive survey of LLMs, but also expose their applications in the judicial system. We first provide an overview of AI technologies in the legal field and showcase the recent research in LLMs. Then, we discuss the practical implementation presented by legal LLMs, such as providing legal advice to users and assisting judges during trials. In addition, we explore the limitations of legal LLMs, including data, algorithms, and judicial practice. Finally, we summarize practical recommendations and propose future development directions to address these challenges.
Computation and Language,Artificial Intelligence
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### What problems does this paper attempt to solve? The paper "Large Language Models in Law: A Review" aims to comprehensively investigate the applications and development of large language models (LLMs) in the legal field. Specifically, the paper attempts to solve the following main problems: 1. **The Future of Law and AI**: - Explore the future development directions of AI technology in the legal field, especially how large language models will influence the legal industry. 2. **Characteristics and Deficiencies of Legal LLMs**: - Analyze the characteristics of legal LLMs, including their abilities in language understanding, content generation, speech - to - text, etc. - Discuss the limitations of these models in practical applications, such as data set defects, algorithm deficiencies, and challenges in judicial practice. 3. **Whether Legal LLMs May Replace the Role of Judges**: - Explore the auxiliary role of legal LLMs in judicial decision - making and whether they may completely replace the role of judges in the future. 4. **Suggestions for Improving Legal LLMs**: - Propose specific improvement suggestions and future research directions to improve the performance and reliability of legal LLMs. ### Main contributions of the paper 1. **The First Comprehensive Review of Legal LLMs**: - This is the first review article to systematically review legal LLMs, introducing the basic concepts of AI and law, describing in detail the characteristics of legal LLMs, and showing the differences between traditional judgments and AI - assisted judgments. 2. **Show How Legal LLMs Can Help Judges Make More Just Decisions**: - Explore in detail how to optimize judicial practice through legal LLMs and propose optimization suggestions based on big data and the characteristics of complex judicial practice. 3. **Provide the Latest Research on Legal LLMs**: - Summarize the latest research on legal LLMs by companies and universities and analyze in depth model fine - tuning techniques and evaluation strategies. 4. **Summarize Key Challenges and Future Directions**: - Analyze the challenges faced by legal LLMs from multiple perspectives such as legal data, algorithms, traditional justice, judicial practice, and human social ethics, and propose specific improvement suggestions and future research directions. ### Organizational structure - **Part 1: Introduction** - Introduce the basic concepts of AI and law and summarize the research background and purpose of the paper. - **Part 2: Key Technologies of LLMs** - Introduce concepts and technologies related to LLMs, including machine learning, neural networks, deep learning, self - attention mechanisms, etc. - **Part 3: Development of Judicial Technology** - Analyze the characteristics of traditional justice, the characteristics of legal big data, and the application characteristics of AI in legal judgments. - **Part 4: Recent Applications** - Based on the recently popular fine - tuning of large legal models and model evaluation methods, focus on discussing their applications. - **Part 5: Challenges** - Analyze the challenges faced by legal LLMs from multiple perspectives such as legal data, algorithms, traditional justice, judicial practice, and human social ethics. - **Part 6: Future Directions** - Propose specific improvement suggestions and future research directions, covering data and infrastructure, algorithm levels, traditional justice processing, and judicial practice, etc. - **Part 7: Conclusion** - Summarize the full text and emphasize the importance of legal LLMs and the potential for future development. Through these contents, the paper provides readers with a comprehensive understanding and in - depth analysis of legal LLMs, providing valuable references for future research and applications.