Exploration of oxyfluoride frameworks as Na-ion cathodes

Debolina Deb,Gopalakrishnan Sai Gautam

2024-05-13

Abstract:Na-ion batteries (NIBs) are increasingly looked at as a viable alternative to Li-ion batteries due to the abundance, low cost, and thermal stability of Na-based systems. To improve the practical utilization of NIBs in applications, it is important to boost the energy and power densities of the electrodes being used, via discovery of novel candidate materials. Thus, we explore the chemical space of transition metal containing oxyfluorides (TMOFs) that adopt the perovskite structure as possible NIB electrodes. Our choice of the perovskite structure is motivated by the `large' cationic tunnels that can accommodate Na$^+$, while the chemistry of TMOFs is motivated by the high electronegativity and inductive effect of F$^-$, which can possibly lead to higher voltages. We use density functional theory based calculations to estimate the ground state polymorphs, average Na (de)intercalation voltages, thermodynamic stabilities and Na$^+$ mobility on two distinct sets of compositions: the F-rich Na$_{x}$MOF$_{2}$, and the O-rich Na$_{1+x}$MO$_{2}$F where $x$ = 0--1 and M~=~Ti, V, Cr, Mn, Fe, Co, or Ni. Upon identifying the ground state polymorphs in the charged compositions (i.e., MOF$_2$ and NaMO$_2$F), we show that F-rich perovskites exhibit higher average voltages compared to O-rich perovskites. Also, we find six stable/metastable perovskites in the F-rich space, while all O-rich perovskites (except NaTiO$_2$F) are unstable. Finally, our Na-ion mobility calculations indicate that TiOF$_{2}$-NaTiOF$_2$, VOF$_{2}$-NaVOF$_2$, CrOF$_{2}$, and NaMnOF$_{2}$ can be promising compositions for experimental exploration as NIB cathodes, primarily if used in a strained electrode configuration and/or thin film batteries. Our computational approach and findings provide insights into developing practical NIBs involving fluorine-containing intercalation frameworks.

Materials Science

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper mainly discusses the possibility of oxyfluorides as cathode materials for sodium-ion batteries (NIBs). Currently, NIBs are considered as feasible alternatives to lithium-ion batteries due to their abundant resources, low cost, and good thermal stability. In this study, the authors focus on improving the energy and power density of battery electrodes by exploring transition metal oxyfluorides (TMOFs) with a perovskite-like structure. They choose the perovskite structure because of its large cation channels that can accommodate sodium ions, and the high electronegativity of fluorine ions in oxyfluorides may result in higher intercalation/deintercalation voltage.

The paper uses density functional theory-based computational methods to estimate the stable phases, average sodium insertion/deinsertion voltage, thermodynamic stability, and sodium ion migration rate of two different compositions of F-enriched (Na_xMOF_2) and O-enriched (Na_{1+x}MO_2F) compounds at different charge states. The study finds that the F-enriched perovskite exhibits higher average voltage than the O-enriched one, and there are six stable/metastable perovskite phases in the F-enriched space, while all O-enriched perovskites (except NaTiO_2F) are unstable. The calculated sodium ion migration rate suggests that TiOF_2-NaTiOF_2, VOF_2-NaVOF_2, CrOF_2, and NaMnOF_2 could be promising NIB cathode candidate materials for experimental exploration, especially in strain electrode configurations or thin film batteries.

Despite the synthesis challenges, this work systematically explores the potential of TMOFs, which have not been fully studied, as NIB cathodes using computational methods, providing new insights for the development of practical NIB applications.