Computational analysis of US Congressional speeches reveals a shift from evidence to intuition

Segun Taofeek Aroyehun,Almog Simchon,Fabio Carrella,Jana Lasser,Stephan Lewandowsky,David Garcia
2024-05-13
Abstract:Pursuit of honest and truthful decision-making is crucial for governance and accountability in democracies. However, people sometimes take different perspectives of what it means to be honest and how to pursue truthfulness. Here we explore a continuum of perspectives from evidence-based reasoning, rooted in ascertainable facts and data, at one end, to intuitive decisions that are driven by feelings and subjective interpretations, at the other. We analyze the linguistic traces of those contrasting perspectives in Congressional speeches from 1879 to 2022. We find that evidence-based language has continued to decline since the mid-1970s, together with a decline in legislative productivity. The decline was accompanied by increasing partisan polarization in Congress and rising income inequality in society. Results highlight the importance of evidence-based language in political decision-making.
General Economics,Computers and Society
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper attempts to address the following issues: by analyzing the linguistic changes in U.S. Congressional speeches, it explores the trend of shifting from evidence-based language to intuition-based language and its impact on the health of democracy. Specifically, the author focuses on the following aspects: 1. **Trends in Linguistic Changes**: The study examines the trend of linguistic changes in U.S. Congressional speeches from 1879 to 2022, shifting from evidence-based language (relying on facts, data, and other external realities) to intuition-based language (relying on feelings, personal values, and other internal experiences). 2. **Relationship Between Political Polarization and Income Inequality**: It analyzes the relationship between this linguistic change trend and political polarization (increased partisan division) and income inequality. The research indicates that as evidence-based language decreases, political polarization and income inequality tend to rise. 3. **Impact on Legislative Productivity**: It explores the role of evidence-based language in the legislative process and how this linguistic change affects Congressional legislative productivity. The study finds that evidence-based language is positively correlated with higher legislative productivity. In summary, the paper aims to reveal the potential impacts of these linguistic changes on democratic governance, social cohesion, and legislative effectiveness through a quantitative analysis of Congressional speeches.