A causal inference approach of monosynapses from spike trains

Zach Saccomano,Sam Mckenzie,Horacio Rotstein,Asohan Amarasingham
2024-05-05
Abstract:Neuroscientists have worked on the problem of estimating synaptic properties, such as connectivity and strength, from simultaneously recorded spike trains since the 1960s. Recent years have seen renewed interest in the problem, coinciding with rapid advances in the technology of high-density neural recordings and optogenetics, which can be used to calibrate causal hypotheses about functional connectivity. Here, a rigorous causal inference framework for pairwise excitatory and inhibitory monosynaptic effects between spike trains is developed. Causal interactions are identified by separating spike interactions in pairwise spike trains by their timescales. Fast algorithms for computing accurate estimates of associated quantities are also developed. Through the lens of this framework, the link between biophysical parameters and statistical definitions of causality between spike trains is examined across a spectrum of dynamical systems simulations. In an idealized setting, we demonstrate a correspondence between the synaptic causal metric developed here and the probabilities of causation developed by Tian and Pearl. Since the probabilities of causation are derived under distinct assumptions and include data from experimental randomization, this opens up the possibility of testing the synaptic inference framework's assumptions with juxtacellular or optogenetic stimulation. We simulate such an experiment with a biophysically detailed channelrhodopsin model and show that randomization is not achieved; strong confounding persists even with strong stimulations. A principal goal is to ask how carefully articulated causal assumptions might better inform the design of neural stimulation experiments and, in turn, support experimental tests of those assumptions.
Neurons and Cognition
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### What problem does this paper attempt to solve? This paper aims to solve the problem of estimating synaptic properties (such as connectivity and strength) from simultaneously recorded neuronal spike trains. Specifically, the author has developed a rigorous causal inference framework for identifying pairwise excitatory and inhibitory monosynaptic effects and determining causal interactions by separating the time scales in pairwise spike trains. #### Main research background Since the 1960s, neuroscientists have been studying how to estimate synaptic properties from simultaneously recorded spike trains. In recent years, with the rapid development of high - density neural recording techniques and optogenetic techniques, this field has attracted wide attention again. These techniques can be used to calibrate causal hypotheses regarding functional connectivity. #### Core contributions of the paper 1. **Causal inference framework**: The author has developed a rigorous causal inference framework based on the time - scale separation hypothesis for identifying pairwise excitatory and inhibitory monosynaptic effects. This framework identifies causal interactions by separating the time scales in pairwise spike trains. 2. **Fast algorithm**: In order to accurately estimate relevant quantities, the author has also developed efficient computational algorithms. 3. **Connection between causality and statistical definition**: Through this framework, the author has explored the connection between biophysical parameters and the statistical causal definition between spike trains, and has shown the correspondence between the synaptic causal measure they developed and the causal probability proposed by Tian and Pearl in an idealized setting. 4. **Experimental verification**: The author has used detailed channelrhodopsin model simulation experiments to test the assumptions of the synaptic inference framework and has shown that even under strong stimulation, strong confounding factors still exist. 5. **Experimental design suggestions**: The author has proposed how to better guide the design of neural stimulation experiments by carefully elaborating causal hypotheses and supports the experimental testing of these hypotheses. #### Specific problem description - **Reliability of monosynaptic input**: Experimental evidence shows that in some neuron pairs, monosynaptic input can reliably produce postsynaptic spike responses in vivo, with millisecond - level time delays and precision. - **Interpretation of millisecond - level correlations**: The most reasonable explanation is that appropriately time - correlated millisecond - level correlations are caused by monosynaptic connections between two cells. - **Relationship between correlation and synaptic strength**: There is evidence that the magnitude of this fine - time - scale correlation covaries with synaptic strength. - **Limitations of statistical methods**: Many existing monosynaptic inference methods rely on cross - correlation graphs (CCG), but under the time - and - scale - separation hypothesis, CCG is insufficient to identify synaptic properties, even in simple models. #### Research objectives The main objective of this paper is to develop robust and rigorous causal inference methods for monosynaptic inference, explicitly model causal relationships, and verify the effectiveness of these methods through simulation and theoretical analysis. In addition, the author has also explored how to experimentally verify these causal hypotheses and has proposed directions for future research. ### Summary This paper is dedicated to solving the challenge of estimating synaptic properties from spike trains, especially by developing a rigorous causal inference framework to identify monosynaptic effects. This framework not only provides a theoretical basis but also develops efficient algorithms and verifies its effectiveness through simulation experiments.