Confronting the Diversity Problem: The Limits of Galaxy Rotation Curves as a tool to Understand Dark Matter Profiles

Isabel S. Sands,Philip F. Hopkins,Xuejian Shen,Michael Boylan-Kolchin,James Bullock,Claude-Andre Faucher-Giguere,Francisco J. Mercado,Jorge Moreno,Lina Necib,Xiaowei Ou,Sarah Wellons,Andrew Wetzel

2024-04-25

Abstract:While galaxy rotation curves provide one of the most powerful methods for measuring dark matter profiles in the inner regions of rotation-supported galaxies, at the dwarf scale there are factors that can complicate this analysis. Given the expectation of a universal profile in dark matter-only simulations, the diversity of observed rotation curves has become an often-discussed issue in Lambda Cold Dark Matter cosmology on galactic scales. We analyze a suite of Feedback in Realistic Environments (FIRE) simulations of $10^{10}-10^{12}$ $M_\odot$ halos with standard cold dark matter, and compare the true circular velocity to rotation curve reconstructions. We find that, for galaxies with well-ordered gaseous disks, the measured rotation curve may deviate from true circular velocity by at most 10% within the radius of the disk. However, non-equilibrium behavior, non-circular motions, and non-thermal and non-kinetic stresses may cause much larger discrepancies of 50% or more. Most rotation curve reconstructions underestimate the true circular velocity, while some reconstructions transiently over-estimate it in the central few kiloparsecs due to dynamical phenomena. We further demonstrate that the features that contribute to these failures are not always visibly obvious in HI observations. If such dwarf galaxies are included in galaxy catalogs, they may give rise to the appearance of "artificial" rotation curve diversity that does not reflect the true variation in underlying dark matter profiles.

Astrophysics of Galaxies,Cosmology and Nongalactic Astrophysics,High Energy Physics - Phenomenology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the limitation of using galactic rotation curves to understand the distribution profile of dark matter on the scale of dwarf galaxies. Specifically, the paper explores the inconsistency between the observed diversity of dwarf - galaxy rotation curves and theoretical predictions in the framework of Λ cold dark matter (ΛCDM) cosmology. This diversity problem not only involves the traditional cusp - versus - core problem, but also extends to the evidence for the existence of highly concentrated and extended but low - density core dwarf galaxies. By analyzing dark halos with masses from 10^10 to 10^12 solar masses in the Feedback in Realistic Environments (FIRE) simulations, the research team compared the real circular velocities with the results of rotation - curve reconstructions, aiming to evaluate the effectiveness of rotation curves as a tool for probing dark - matter distributions.

The key points mentioned in the paper include:

1. **Deviations of rotation curves**: For galaxies with well - ordered gas disks, the measured rotation curves may deviate from the real circular velocities by at most about 10% within the disk radius. However, non - equilibrium behaviors, non - circular motions, and non - thermal and non - dynamical stresses may lead to larger differences, reaching 50% or more.

2. **Underestimation and overestimation in rotation - curve reconstructions**: Most rotation - curve reconstructions underestimate the real circular velocities, while within the central few kpc, some reconstructions temporarily overestimate the circular velocities due to dynamical phenomena.

3. **"Artificial" diversity in observations**: The paper points out that if these dwarf galaxies are included in the galaxy catalog, it may lead to an "artificial" rotation - curve diversity, which does not reflect the real changes in the underlying dark - matter distribution.

4. **Influence of assumptions**: The paper emphasizes that the measurement of rotation curves is based on several fundamental assumptions, such as that the galaxies are in a steady - state equilibrium and have spherical symmetry. When these assumptions do not hold, especially when there are complex non - circular motions, the rotation curves may not accurately track the dark - matter distribution.

In summary, through a detailed analysis of FIRE simulation data, this paper explores the limitations of rotation curves as a tool for probing dark - matter distributions on the scale of dwarf galaxies, especially when the galaxies are in a non - equilibrium state or there are complex dynamical processes. Rotation curves may significantly deviate from the real dark - matter distribution. This research is of great significance for understanding the applicability of ΛCDM cosmology on small scales.