Abstract:It is routinely assumed that galaxy rotation curves are equal to their circular velocity curves (modulo some corrections) such that they are good dynamical mass tracers. We take a visualisation-driven approach to exploring the limits of the validity of this assumption for a sample of $33$ low-mass galaxies ($60<v_\mathrm{max}/\mathrm{km}\,\mathrm{s}^{-1}<120$) from the APOSTLE suite of cosmological hydrodynamical simulations. Only $3$ of these have rotation curves nearly equal to their circular velocity curves at $z=0$, the rest are undergoing a wide variety of dynamical perturbations. We use our visualisations to guide an assessment of how many galaxies are likely to be strongly perturbed by processes in several categories: mergers/interactions (affecting $6$/$33$ galaxies), bulk radial gas inflows ($19$/$33$), vertical gas outflows ($15$/$33$), distortions driven by a non-spherical DM halo ($17$/$33$), warps ($8$/$33$), and winds due to motion through the IGM ($5$/$33$). Most galaxies fall into more than one of these categories; only $5$/$33$ are not in any of them. The sum of these effects leads to an underestimation of the low-velocity slope of the baryonic Tully-Fisher relation ($\alpha\sim 3.1$ instead of $\alpha\sim 3.9$, where $M_\mathrm{bar}\propto v^\alpha$) that is difficult to avoid, and could plausibly be the source of a significant portion of the observed diversity in low-mass galaxy rotation curve shapes.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper primarily explores the effectiveness of rotation curves of low-mass galaxies as tracers of their mass distribution. Specifically, the study focuses on whether these galaxies' rotation curves can accurately reflect their circular velocity curves, thereby serving as good indicators of dynamical mass. ### Research Background and Motivation - **Importance of Rotation Curves**: Since the discovery of flat rotation curves in galaxies (Rubin et al. 1980; Bosma 1981), they have become an important tool for studying dark matter. For low-mass galaxies with a maximum circular velocity not exceeding approximately 120 km/s, their rotation curves almost directly reflect the distribution of dark matter due to their high dark matter content. - **Baryonic Tully-Fisher Relation (BTFR)**: This relation describes the relationship between a galaxy's baryonic (gas plus stars) mass and its maximum rotation speed, typically considered to follow a fourth power law. However, if the mass ratio of stars to dark matter is assumed to be constant, the expected relationship should be closer to a third power law, indicating that the observed BTFR slope is shallower than theoretically predicted. ### Research Methods and Results - **Simulation Data**: The study used cosmological hydrodynamical simulation data from the APOSTLE suite, particularly a sample of 33 low-mass galaxies with maximum circular velocities between 60 and 120 km/s. Using these simulation data, researchers analyzed the galaxies' rotation curves, circular velocity curves, and various physical processes affecting these curves. - **Visual Analysis**: To intuitively understand the dynamical state of these galaxies, the authors created a series of visual images and videos to explore the reasons behind the deviation of rotation curves from circular velocity curves. These visualization tools helped identify different types of disturbances, such as merger events, radial gas inflows, and vertical gas outflows. - **Disturbance Classification**: Based on visual analysis, the authors classified these disturbances and assessed their impact on the shape of galaxy rotation curves. For example, the study found that approximately 6 galaxies were affected by merger events, and 19 galaxies experienced significant radial gas inflows. ### Conclusion - **Reliability Issues of Rotation Curves**: The study pointed out that in many cases, the rotation curves of low-mass galaxies do not well trace their circular velocity curves, thereby underestimating the low-velocity slope of the Baryonic Tully-Fisher Relation (from α ≈ 3.1 to α ≈ 3.9). This bias is difficult to avoid and may be an important reason for the observed diversity in the shapes of low-mass galaxy rotation curves. - **Impact on Theoretical Models**: These findings are significant for understanding the formation and evolution of low-mass galaxies and their relationship with dark matter halos. Additionally, it suggests that we need to reconsider how to use rotation curves to constrain dark matter theories and galaxy formation models. In summary, this paper reveals the challenges faced by using rotation curves of low-mass galaxies as indicators of dynamical mass through the study of a series of simulated galaxies and provides new insights into this issue.

The many reasons that the rotation curves of low-mass galaxies can fail as tracers of their matter distributions

The unexpected diversity of dwarf galaxy rotation curves

Confronting the Diversity Problem: The Limits of Galaxy Rotation Curves as a tool to Understand Dark Matter Profiles

Non-circular motions and the diversity of dwarf galaxy rotation curves

The diversity of rotation curves of simulated galaxies with cusps and cores

Missing dark matter in dwarf galaxies?

KURVS: The outer rotation curve shapes and dark matter fractions of $z \sim 1.5 $ star-forming galaxies

Recent observations of the rotation of distant galaxies and the implication for dark matter

Declining rotation curves at $z=2$ in $Λ$CDM galaxy formation simulations

The low-mass end of the baryonic Tully-Fisher relation

An overlooked source of uncertainty in the mass of the Milky Way

On the Galactic rotation curve inferred from the Jeans equations Assessing its robustness using Gaia DR3 and cosmological simulations

Rotation curves of galaxies in GR

Can rotation explain the multiple main sequence turn-offs of Magellanic Cloud star clusters?

Implications of the Milky Way Declining Rotation Curve

Gravitomagnetism and galaxy rotation curves: a cautionary tale

Generalized rotation curves of the Milky Way from the GAIA DR3 data-set: constraints on mass models

Galaxy rotation curves with log-normal density distribution

Gravothermal collapse and the diversity of galactic rotation curves

Physical Explanation for the Galaxy Distribution on the $(\lambda_{\rm R}, \varepsilon)$ and $(V/\sigma, \varepsilon)$ Diagrams or for the Limit on Orbital Anisotropy