Spectral Density and Sum Rules for Second-Order Response Functions

Barry Bradlyn,Peter Abbamonte

2024-04-25

Abstract:Sum rules for linear response functions give powerful and experimentally-relevant relations between frequency moments of response functions and ground state properties. In particular, renewed interest has been drawn to optical conductivity and density-density sum rules and their connection to quantum geometry in topological materials. At the same time, recent work has also illustrated the connection between quantum geometry and second-order nonlinear response functions in quantum materials, motivating the search for exact sum rules for second-order response that can provide experimental probes and theoretical constraints for geometry and topology in these systems. Here we begin to address these questions by developing a general formalism for deriving sum rules for second-order response functions. Using generalized Kramers-Kronig relations, we show that the second-order Kubo formula can be expressed in terms of a spectral density that is a sum of Dirac delta functions in frequency. We show that moments of the spectral density can be expressed in terms of averages of equal-time commutators, yielding a family of generalized sum rules; furthermore, these sum rules constrain the large-frequency asymptotic behavior of the second harmonic generation rate. We apply our formalism to study generalized $f$-sum rules for the second-order density-density response function and the longitudinal nonlinear conductivity. We show that for noninteracting electrons in solids, the generalized $f$-sum rule can be written entirely in terms of matrix elements of the Bloch Hamiltonian. Finally, we derive a family of sum rules for rectification response, determining the large-frequency asymptotic behavior of the time-independent response to a harmonic perturbation.

Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics,Statistical Mechanics,Strongly Correlated Electrons

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### Problems the paper attempts to solve

This paper aims to solve the problems related to spectral density and sum rules associated with second - order response functions. Specifically, the paper focuses on how to derive sum rules applicable to second - order response functions by developing a formal theory. These sum rules are of great significance for understanding and experimentally probing the geometric and topological properties in quantum materials.

### Background and motivation

1. **Sum rules of linear response functions**:
- The sum rules of linear response functions are some exact results in many - body physics and are crucial for interpreting spectroscopy experiments. For example, the well - known \( f \)-sum rule links the total electron density in solids to the absorption probability of light, imposing strict constraints on the optical properties of materials.
- In recent years, the sum rules of more general conductivity tensor moments have been studied. These rules are related to polarization fluctuations in the ground state of many - body systems and are further related to quantum geometry.

2. **Importance of nonlinear response functions**:
- Nonlinear response functions, especially second - order response functions, are becoming increasingly important in the study of topological materials. These functions are related to the nonlinear conductivity of quantum systems and the Riemannian geometry of quantum states.
- Sum rules can provide important theoretical constraints and serve as experimental probes for calibrating nonlinear spectroscopic measurements, similar to what is done in linear spectroscopy.

### Main contributions

1. **Spectral representation of second - order response functions**:
- By introducing spectral density, the author expresses the second - order Kubo formula in the integral form of frequency. This enables the high - frequency behavior of the second - order response function to be described by the moments of spectral density.
- Through the generalized Kramers - Kronig relations, the author shows that the spectral density moments of the second - order response function can be expressed by the average values of equal - time commutators, thus obtaining a series of second - order sum rules.

2. **Specific applications**:
- The author applies these sum rules to the second - harmonic - generation response and derives relevant sum rules, which have practical significance in experiments.
- For non - interacting electron systems, the author shows how to express the generalized \( f \)-sum rule completely in terms of the matrix elements of the Bloch Hamiltonian.
- The author also derives the sum rules for a class of rectification responses and determines the asymptotic behavior of time - independent responses at high frequencies.

### Conclusion

By developing a formal theory, the author has successfully derived a series of sum rules applicable to second - order response functions. These rules not only provide new tools for theoretical research but also provide important means for experimentally probing the geometric and topological properties in quantum materials. These results are of great significance for understanding nonlinear optical processes and calibrating related experiments.