Abstract:Using chiral effective field theory, we predict that there must be isovector charmonium-like $D\bar D^*$ hadronic molecules with $J^{PC}=1^{++}$ denoted as $W_{c1}$. The inputs are the properties of the $X(3872)$, including its mass and the ratio of its branching fractions of decays into $J/\psi\rho^0$ and $J/\psi\omega$. The predicted states are virtual state poles of the scattering matrix, pointing at a molecular nature of the $X(3872)$ as well as its spin partners. They should show up as either a mild cusp or dip at the $D\bar D^*$ thresholds, explaining why they are elusive in experiments. The so far negative observation also indicates that the $X(3872)$ is either a bound state with non-vanishing binding energy or a virtual state, only in these cases the $X(3872)$ signal dominates over that from the $W_{c1}^0$. The pole positions are $3881.2^{+0.8}_{-0.0}- i 1.6^{+0.7}_{-0.9}$ MeV for $W_{c1}^0$ on the fourth Riemann sheet of the $D^0\bar D^{*0}$-$D^+D^{*-}$ coupled-channel system, and $3866.9^{+4.6}_{-7.7}- i (0.07\pm0.01)$ MeV for $W_{c1}^\pm$ on the second Riemann sheet of the $(D\bar D^*)^\pm$ single-channel system. The findings imply that the peak in the $J/\psi\pi^+\pi^-$ invariant mass distribution is not purely from the $X(3872)$ but contains contributions from $W_{c1}^0$ predicted here. The states should have isovector heavy quark spin partners with $J^{PC}=0^{++}$, $2^{++}$ and $1^{+-}$, with the last one corresponding to $Z_c$. We suggest to search for the charged $0^{++}$, $1^{++}$ and $2^{++}$ states in $J/\psi\pi^\pm \pi^0$.

How does the $X(3872)$ show up in $e^+e^-$ collisions: dip versus peak

How does the show up in collisions: Dip versus peak

Nature of X(3872) from recent BESIII data: Considering the universal feature of an S-wave threshold resonance

Investigation of the $X(4020)$ peak in the $D^\bar D^$ and $πh_c$ channels

Charged charmoniumlike structures in the $e^+ e^- \to ψ(3686) π^+ π^-$ process based on the ISPE mechanism

Production of the $X(4014)$ as the spin-2 partner of $X(3872)$ in $e^+e^-$ collisions

Poles and Poltergeists in $e^+ e^- \to D \bar D$ Data

Isospin Breaking, Coupled-Channel Effects, and X(3872)

Observation of a charged (DDbar)- mass peak in e+e- --> pi+ (DDbar)- at Ecm=4.26 GeV

A new look at $ψ(4160)$ and $ψ(4230)$

Predicting isovector charmonium-like states from X(3872) properties

Production of the spin partner of the X(3872) in e^+e^- collisions

Combined analysis on nature of $X(3960)$, $χ_{c0}(3930)$, and $X_0(4140)$

A discussion on the anomalous threshold enhancement of $J/ψ$ -- $ψ(3770)$ couplings and $X(6900)$ peak

The pole structures of the $X(1840)/X(1835)$ and the $X(1880)$

How to Understand the X(2900)?

X(3872) revisited: the roles of OPEP and the quark degrees of freedom

Pionic transitions of the spin-2 partner of $X(3872)$ to $χ_{cJ}$

On leptonic width of X(4260)

The role of the short-distance interaction in $e^+e^-\to γX(3872)$

A discussion on the anomalous threshold enhancement of $J/\psi$ -- $\psi(3770)$ couplings and $X(6900)$ peak