Poles and Poltergeists in $e^+ e^- \to D \bar D$ Data

Nils Hüsken,Richard F. Lebed,Ryan E. Mitchell,Eric S. Swanson,Ya-Qian Wang,Chang-Zheng Yuan

2024-04-15

Abstract:A recent report of $e^+ e^- \to D\bar D$ events by the BESIII Collaboration suggests the presence of a structure $R$ at 3900~MeV\@. We argue that this structure, called $G(3900)$ in the past, is not in fact due to a new $c\bar c$ resonance, but rather naturally emerges as a threshold enhancement due to the opening of the $D^*\bar D$ channel. We further find that the appearance of this structure does not require suppression because of a radial node in the $\psi(4040)$ wave function, although a node improves fit quality. The measured $e^+ e^-$ coupling of $\psi(4040)$ is found to be substantially smaller than previously estimated. In addition, we report new corrections to the measured cross section $\sigma(e^+ e^- \to D\bar D)$ at energies near $\psi(3770)$.

High Energy Physics - Phenomenology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is whether a structure (called G(3900)) observed in \(D\bar{D}\) events produced during the electron - positron collision process is a new \(c\bar{c}\) resonant state. Specifically, the paper explores the following points:

1. **Nature of the structure**: The BESIII collaboration reported the data - fitting results of \(D\bar{D}\) events in the \(e^+e^-\) collision process. A possible new resonant state was labeled as R(3900), with a mass \(m = 3872\pm14\pm3 \, \text{MeV}\) and a width \(\Gamma = 180\pm14\pm7 \, \text{MeV}\). However, other experiments such as BaBar and Belle also observed similar peak structures but did not attribute them to new resonant states.

2. **Threshold enhancement mechanism**: The paper discusses whether this structure can be naturally explained by the opening of the \(D^*\bar{D}\) threshold rather than being a new resonant state. The authors cited the classical model calculations of the Cornell group, which predicted an enhancement near 3900 MeV due to the opening of the \(D^*\bar{D}\) threshold.

3. **Effect of radial nodes**: The paper also explores whether the radial nodes in the \(\psi(4040)\) wave function will affect the appearance of this structure. The authors found that although radial nodes can improve the fitting quality, they are not necessary for explaining this structure.

4. **Revised measured cross - section**: The paper reports new revisions to the measured cross - section of \(e^+e^-\) to \(D\bar{D}\) near \(\psi(3770)\).

Through these analyses, the paper aims to verify whether G(3900) is really a new resonant state or merely the result of a threshold effect. Eventually, the authors conclude that G(3900) is more likely to be a threshold enhancement due to the opening of the \(D^*\bar{D}\) threshold rather than a new \(c\bar{c}\) resonant state.