A Systematic Survey of the Gemini Principles for Digital Twin Ontologies

James Michael Tooth,Nilufer Tuptuk,Jeremy Daniel McKendrick Watson
2024-04-17
Abstract:Ontologies are widely used for achieving interoperable Digital Twins (DTws), yet competing DTw definitions compound interoperability issues. Semantically linking these differing twins is feasible through ontologies and Cognitive Digital Twins (CDTws). However, it is often unclear how ontology use bolsters broader DTw advancements. This article presents a systematic survey following the PRISMA method, to explore the potential of ontologies to support DTws to meet the Centre for Digital Built Britain's Gemini Principles and aims to link progress in ontologies to this framework. The Gemini Principles focus on common DTw requirements, considering: Purpose for 1) Public Good, 2) Value Creation, and 3) Insight; Trustworthiness with sufficient 4) Security, 5) Openness, and 6) Quality; and appropriate Functionality of 7) Federation, 8) Curation, and 9) Evolution. This systematic literature review examines the role of ontologies in facilitating each principle. Existing research uses ontologies to solve DTw challenges within these principles, particularly by connecting DTws, optimising decisionmaking, and reasoning governance policies. Furthermore, analysing the sectoral distribution of literature found that research encompassing the crossover of ontologies, DTws and the Gemini Principles is emerging, and that most innovation is predominantly within manufacturing and built environment sectors. Critical gaps for researchers, industry practitioners, and policymakers are subsequently identified.
Emerging Technologies,Computers and Society,Human-Computer Interaction,Systems and Control
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper primarily explores how Digital Twins (DTw) in various industries can meet the Gemini principles with the support of ontologies. Specifically, the paper attempts to answer the following core questions: 1. **How do ontologies help Digital Twins adhere to the Gemini principles?** By reviewing current research progress and identifying areas of consensus and controversy, the paper aims to better align future research with the broader development of the Digital Twins field. 2. **How are publications related to ontologies and one or more Gemini principles distributed across different industries and timelines?** To understand the existing research landscape and future evolution trends, and to identify cross-industry synergies or advancements, enabling future work to recognize and fill cross-industry gaps. 3. **In which research, policy, and industry areas are there gaps that can be enhanced by the application of ontologies to improve Digital Twins' adherence to the Gemini principles?** To identify key areas where ontologies can improve the design and implementation of Digital Twins, helping stakeholders prioritize future work directions. The paper uses a systematic literature review method to analyze the potential of ontologies in supporting Digital Twins to meet the Gemini principles and assesses the distribution and temporal changes of the combination of ontologies and Digital Twins across different industries. Additionally, it explores the concept of Cognitive Digital Twins (CDTws), which integrate machine learning and ontology methods to achieve higher levels of automated decision-making and support. In summary, this paper aims to guide future research, policy-making, and industrial practices by examining in detail how ontologies can promote the development and application of Digital Twin technology, particularly in meeting the requirements of the Gemini principles.