Research and Practice of Delivering Tabletop Exercises

Jan Vykopal,Pavel Čeleda,Valdemar Švábenský,Martin Hofbauer,Martin Horák
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1145/3649217.3653642
2024-04-16
Abstract:Tabletop exercises are used to train personnel in the efficient mitigation and resolution of incidents. They are applied in practice to support the preparedness of organizations and to highlight inefficient processes. Since tabletop exercises train competencies required in the workplace, they have been introduced into computing courses at universities as an innovation, especially within cybersecurity curricula. To help computing educators adopt this innovative method, we survey academic publications that deal with tabletop exercises. From 140 papers we identified and examined, we selected 14 papers for a detailed review. The results show that the existing research deals predominantly with exercises that follow a linear format and exercises that do not systematically collect data about trainees' learning. Computing education researchers can investigate novel approaches to instruction and assessment in the context of tabletop exercises to maximize the impact of this teaching method. Due to the relatively low number of published papers, the potential for future research is immense. Our review provides researchers, tool developers, and educators with an orientation in the area, a synthesis of trends, and implications for further work.
Computers and Society
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problems that this paper attempts to solve are: **How to introduce Tabletop Exercises (TTX), an effective training method, into the teaching practice of computing courses, especially cyber - security courses, and explore its application and development potential in education.** Specifically, through a systematic literature review, the paper discusses the following aspects: 1. **Formats and Tools of Tabletop Exercises**: How different types of tabletop exercises are prepared and implemented, and what tools are used. 2. **Backgrounds of Participants and Organizers**: Who are the main participants in tabletop exercises, what fields or organizations they come from, and who organizes these exercises. 3. **Development, Assessment and Evaluation of Exercises**: The design process of tabletop exercises, the assessment methods for participants, and the evaluation methods for the exercises themselves. 4. **Application of Research Results**: Whether the existing research provides supplementary materials or tools that can be directly applied to teaching practice. 5. **Future Research Directions and Challenges**: The deficiencies of current research and possible future research directions. Through the screening of 140 related literatures and the detailed analysis of 14 key literatures, the paper aims to provide educators, researchers and educational tool developers with an overview of the current situation of tabletop exercises, trend analysis and implications for future work. This helps to promote the wide application of tabletop exercises in higher education institutions, especially in cultivating students' practical working abilities and the abilities to respond to emergencies.