Device-independent quantum key distribution based on routed Bell tests

Tristan Le Roy-Deloison,Edwin Peter Lobo,Jef Pauwels,Stefano Pironio

2024-04-01

Abstract:Photon losses are the main obstacle to fully photonic implementations of device-independent quantum key distribution (DIQKD). Motivated by recent work showing that routed Bell scenarios offer increased robustness to detection inefficiencies for the certification of long-range quantum correlations, we investigate DIQKD protocols based on a routed setup. In these protocols, in some of the test rounds, photons from the source are routed by an actively controlled switch to a nearby test device instead of the distant one. We show how to analyze the security of these protocols and compute lower bounds on the key rates using non-commutative polynomial optimization and the Brown-Fawzi-Fazwi method. We determine lower bounds on the asymptotic key rates of several simple two-qubit routed DIQKD protocols based on CHSH or BB84 correlations and compare their performance to standard protocols. We find that in an ideal case routed DIQKD protocols can significantly improve detection efficiency requirements, by up to $\sim 30\%$, compared to their non-routed counterparts. Notably, the routed BB84 protocol achieves a positive key rate with a detection efficiency as low as $50\%$ for the distant device, the minimal threshold for any QKD protocol featuring two untrusted measurements. However, the advantages we find are highly sensitive to noise and losses affecting the short-range correlations involving the additional test device.

Quantum Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is the impact of photon loss on device - independent quantum key distribution (DIQKD) implemented with all - photons. Specifically, the authors explored the DIQKD protocol based on routed Bell tests, aiming to improve the robustness against imperfect detection efficiency and extend the distance of long - distance quantum correlations that can be authenticated.

### Background problems
1. **Photon loss**: Photon loss is the main obstacle to the all - photon implementation of DIQKD. In practical applications, the inevitable quantum - optical channel loss makes it difficult to achieve a sufficiently high level of efficiency in detecting quantum particles.
2. **Detection efficiency requirements**: High detection efficiency is required to ensure a loophole - free Bell test (i.e., to avoid the detection loophole). For the authentication of long - distance quantum correlations, the requirements for detection efficiency are particularly strict.

### Solution
The authors proposed a method based on **routed Bell tests**. By introducing an additional test device \(T\), some photons are routed to a nearby test device instead of a distant device. This method can reduce the requirements for detection efficiency to a certain extent, thereby overcoming the problem of photon loss.

### Specific contributions
1. **Security analysis**: The authors showed how to analyze the security of these protocols and calculated the lower bounds of the key rate using non - commutative polynomial optimization (NPO) and the Brown - Fawzi - Fazwi method.
2. **Performance comparison**: They determined the asymptotic key rate lower bounds of several simple two - qubit routed DIQKD protocols and compared their performance with that of the standard protocol.
3. **Improvement effect**: In the ideal case, the routed DIQKD protocol can significantly improve the detection efficiency requirements, up to approximately 30%. In particular, the routed BB84 protocol can still obtain a positive key rate when the detection efficiency of the remote device is as low as 50%, which is the lowest threshold for any QKD protocol containing two untrusted measurements.

### Key formulas
- **Correlation probability in the Bell test**:
\[
p(a,c|x,z)=\text{tr}(\rho_{AB}A^a|x\otimes T^c|z)\quad\text{if }s = 0,
\]
\[
p(a,b|x,y)=\text{tr}(\rho_{AB}A^a|x\otimes B^b|y)\quad\text{if }s = 1.
\]

- **Conditional min - entropy**:
\[
H(A|XE)=\inf_{\hat{Q}}H(A|XE)_{\sigma_{AXE}},
\]
where \(\sigma_{AXE}\) is the post - measurement state, defined as:
\[
\sigma_{AXE}=\sum_{ax}p(x)|ax\rangle\langle ax|\otimes\sigma_{a,x}^E,
\]
\[
\sigma_{a,x}^E=\text{tr}_{AB}(|\hat{\Psi}_{ABE}\rangle\langle\hat{\Psi}_{ABE}|(\hat{A}^a|x\otimes I_B\otimes I_E)).
\]

### Summary
This paper provides an effective method to reduce the requirements of DIQKD for detection efficiency by introducing routed Bell tests, thereby improving the feasibility of long - distance quantum correlation authentication.