New protocols for quantum key distribution with explicit upper and lower bound on secret-key rate

Arindam Dutta,Anirban Pathak

2023-09-27

Abstract:Here we present two new schemes for quantum key distribution (QKD) which neither require entanglement nor require an ideal single photon source. Thus, the proposed protocols can be implemented using realistic single photon sources which are commercially available. The schemes are shown to be secure against multiple attacks (e.g., intercept resend attack and a class of collective attacks). Bounds on the key rate are obtained and it is shown that by applying a certain type of classical pre-processing, the tolerable error limit can be increased. A trade-off between quantum resources used and information revealed to Eve is observed and it is shown that by using slightly more quantum resources it is possible to design protocols having higher efficiency compared to a protocol of the same family that uses relatively lesser amount of quantum resources. Specifically, in our case, SARG04 protocol is a protocol of the same family and it is clearly shown that the proposed protocols can provide higher efficiency compared to SARG04 at the cost of consumption of more quantum resources. Further, it is shown that the critical distances for the proposed protocols under photon number splitting (PNS) type attacks are higher than the critical distances obtained for BB84 and SARG04 protocols implemented under similar situation.

Quantum Physics,Cryptography and Security

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper attempts to solve several key problems in Quantum Key Distribution (QKD):

1. **Reducing the dependence on ideal single - photon sources**: Many existing QKD protocols (such as BB84 and SARG04) usually require idealized single - photon sources, which are difficult to achieve in practical applications. The paper proposes two new QKD protocols. These protocols neither require entangled states nor idealized single - photon sources, but can use commercially available practical single - photon sources.

2. **Improving the security and efficiency of the protocol**: The newly proposed protocols can not only resist multiple attacks (such as intercept - resend attacks and a class of collective attacks), but also improve the fault - tolerance rate by introducing classical pre - processing techniques. In addition, the paper explores the trade - off between the amount of quantum resources used and information leakage, and shows that by using more quantum resources, a more efficient scheme than existing protocols (such as SARG04) can be designed.

3. **Increasing the critical distance**: The paper analyzes the performance of the new protocol under Photon Number Splitting (PNS) attacks. The results show that the critical distance of the new protocol is higher than that of the BB84 and SARG04 protocols in similar situations. This means that the new protocol has better security in long - distance communication.

### Specific problem analysis

#### 1. Reducing the dependence on ideal single - photon sources
- **Background**: Most QKD protocols (such as BB84) require idealized single - photon sources, but in practical applications, weak coherent pulses (WCPs) are usually used, which can be approximated as single - photon sources.
- **Solution**: The new protocols proposed in the paper can directly use commercially available practical single - photon sources, thus reducing the implementation difficulty.

#### 2. Improving the security and efficiency of the protocol
- **Background**: Although existing QKD protocols are unconditionally secure in ideal situations, in practical applications, due to imperfect devices, there may be the risk of side - channel attacks.
- **Solution**: The new protocol improves the fault - tolerance rate by introducing classical pre - processing techniques, and in some cases, the efficiency of the protocol can be improved by using more quantum resources. For example, compared with the SARG04 protocol, the new protocol can provide higher efficiency when using more quantum resources.

#### 3. Increasing the critical distance
- **Background**: In long - distance communication, channel loss is an important problem, which enables attackers to use advanced techniques for eavesdropping attacks.
- **Solution**: The paper shows the advantages of the new protocol in critical distance by analyzing the performance under PNS attacks. Specifically, the critical distance of the new protocol under PNS attacks is higher than that of the BB84 and SARG04 protocols, which means that the new protocol has better security in long - distance communication.

### Summary
By proposing two new QKD protocols, the paper solves multiple key problems in the practical application of existing QKD protocols, including the dependence on ideal single - photon sources, the improvement of security and efficiency, and the critical distance problem in long - distance communication. These improvements make QKD technology more feasible and reliable in practical applications.