Abstract:The principle that rational agents should maximize expected utility or choiceworthiness is intuitively plausible in many ordinary cases of decision-making under uncertainty. But it is less plausible in cases of extreme, low-probability risk (like Pascal's Mugging), and intolerably paradoxical in cases like the St. Petersburg and Pasadena games. In this paper I show that, under certain conditions, stochastic dominance reasoning can capture most of the plausible implications of expectational reasoning while avoiding most of its pitfalls. Specifically, given sufficient background uncertainty about the choiceworthiness of one's options, many expectation-maximizing gambles that do not stochastically dominate their alternatives "in a vacuum" become stochastically dominant in virtue of that background uncertainty. But, even under these conditions, stochastic dominance will not require agents to accept options whose expectational superiority depends on sufficiently small probabilities of extreme payoffs. The sort of background uncertainty on which these results depend looks unavoidable for any agent who measures the choiceworthiness of her options in part by the total amount of value in the resulting world. At least for such agents, then, stochastic dominance offers a plausible general principle of choice under uncertainty that can explain more of the apparent rational constraints on such choices than has previously been recognized.

Max-stability under first-order stochastic dominance

A new characterization of second-order stochastic dominance

Maxitive functions with respect to general orders

A Characterization of the n-th Degree Bounded Stochastic Dominance

Utility Maximization, Risk Aversion, and Stochastic Dominance

Stabilizing control of robustness for systems with maximum uncertain parameters - A quadratic programming approach

Minimal Quantile Functions Subject to Stochastic Dominance Constraints

Maximum principle for stochastic optimal control problem under convex expectation

STABILITY OF THE EXPONENTIAL UTILITY MAXIMIZATION PROBLEM WITH RESPECT TO PREFERENCES

Stochastic maximum principle under probability distortion

Maximum principle for discrete-time stochastic optimal control problem under distribution uncertainty

Quantitative Stability Estimate of the Hardy-Littlewood Functional Under Constraints

Stochastic Maximum Principle for Subdiffusions and Its Applications

A Second-Order Maximum Principle for Singular Optimal Stochastic Controls

Robust Stability Analysis for Autonomous Min-Max Systems.

Higher order measures of risk and stochastic dominance

Stability and Generalization of Stochastic Gradient Methods for Minimax Problems

Minimax Optimal Estimation of Stability Under Distribution Shift

On quantitative stability in infinite-dimensional optimization under uncertainty

Maximum principles for partially observed mean-field stochastic systems with application to financial engineering

Exceeding Expectations: Stochastic Dominance as a General Decision Theory