Uncovering the Deep Filter Bubble: Narrow Exposure in Short-Video Recommendation

Nicholas Sukiennik,Chen Gao,Nian Li

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1145/3589334.3648159

2024-03-07

Abstract:Filter bubbles have been studied extensively within the context of online content platforms due to their potential to cause undesirable outcomes such as user dissatisfaction or polarization. With the rise of short-video platforms, the filter bubble has been given extra attention because these platforms rely on an unprecedented use of the recommender system to provide relevant content. In our work, we investigate the deep filter bubble, which refers to the user being exposed to narrow content within their broad interests. We accomplish this using one-year interaction data from a top short-video platform in China, which includes hierarchical data with three levels of categories for each video. We formalize our definition of a "deep" filter bubble within this context, and then explore various correlations within the data: first understanding the evolution of the deep filter bubble over time, and later revealing some of the factors that give rise to this phenomenon, such as specific categories, user demographics, and feedback type. We observe that while the overall proportion of users in a filter bubble remains largely constant over time, the depth composition of their filter bubble changes. In addition, we find that some demographic groups that have a higher likelihood of seeing narrower content and implicit feedback signals can lead to less bubble formation. Finally, we propose some ways in which recommender systems can be designed to reduce the risk of a user getting caught in a bubble.

Artificial Intelligence

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper mainly discusses the problem of "Deep Filter Bubble" on short video platforms, which refers to users being confined to narrow content within their broad interests. The study used one year of interaction data from a top short video platform in China, which included three-level category classification information for each video. The paper first defines the concept of "deep" filter bubble and analyzes various correlations in the data, including temporal evolution and factors contributing to the phenomenon (such as specific categories, demographic characteristics of users, and feedback types). The study found that although the overall proportion of users in filter bubbles remained stable, the composition of their depth was changing, with certain demographic groups seeing narrower content, while implicit feedback signals could reduce the formation of filter bubbles. Finally, the paper proposes methods to design recommendation systems to reduce the risk of users falling into filter bubbles.

The main contributions of the paper are as follows:
1. Proposing a robust method to evaluate the existence and extent of deep filter bubbles.
2. Conducting long-term analysis of deep filter bubbles and their related factors on a large-scale real-world dataset.
3. Providing insights into the design of recommendation systems to prevent or alleviate the formation of deep filter bubbles and create a more diverse user experience.

The authors describe the phenomenon of filter bubbles in detail by introducing the user decision-making process, dataset, and methodology, particularly in the context of short video recommendations. They analyze the influence of different hierarchical categories, user characteristics, and feedback types on filter bubbles and propose strategies for addressing them.