Dynamics of the Non-equilibrium spin Boson Model: A Benchmark of master equations and their validity

Gerardo Suárez,Marcin Łobejko,Michał Horodecki

2024-09-14

Abstract:In recent years, there has been tremendous focus on identifying whether effective descriptions of open quantum systems such as master equations, can accurately describe the dynamics of open quantum systems. One particular question is whether they provide the correct steady state in the long time limit. Transient regime is also of interest. Description of evolution by various master equations - some of them being not complete positive - is benchmarked against exact solutions (see e.g. Hartmann and Strunz, Phys. Rev. A 101, 012103). An important property of true evolution is its non-Markovian features, which are not captured by the simplest completely positive master equations. In this paper we consider a non-Markovian, yet completely positive evolution (known as refined weak coupling or cumulant equation) for the Spin-Boson model with an Overdamped Drude-Lorentz spectral density and arbitrary coupling. We bench-marked it against numerically exact solution, as well as against other master equations, for different coupling strengths and temperatures. We find the cumulant to be a better description in the weak coupling regime where it is supposed to be valid. For the examples considered it shows superiority at moderate and strong couplings in the low-temperature regime for all examples considered. In the high-temperature regime however its advantage vanishes. This indicates that the cumulant equation is a good candidate for simulations at weak to moderate coupling and low temperature. Our calculations are greatly facilitated due to our concise formulation of the cumulant equation by means of representation of the density matrix in the SU(N) basis.

Quantum Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the validity and accuracy of different master equations in describing the system dynamics in the non - equilibrium spin - boson model, especially under non - Markovian conditions. Specifically, the paper focuses on the following points:

1. **Description of non - Markovian effects**: The paper explores the accuracy of different master equations in describing the transient and steady - state behaviors of open quantum systems, especially whether these equations can correctly capture non - Markovian effects.

2. **Correctness of the steady state**: It studies whether different master equations can provide correct steady - state solutions in the long - time limit, especially their performance under high - temperature and low - temperature conditions.

3. **Performance under weak - coupling and strong - coupling conditions**: It evaluates the performance of different master equations under weak - coupling and strong - coupling conditions, especially the advantages and limitations of the cumulant equation under these conditions.

4. **Influence of Lamb shift**: It discusses the influence of Lamb shift on the system dynamics and the steady state, and explores the complexity of Lamb shift under non - Markovian conditions.

5. **Influence of composite interactions**: It considers the composite interactions between the system and the environment, and studies the influence of these interactions on the system dynamics and the steady state.

### Main conclusions

- **Performance of the cumulant equation**: Under weak - coupling conditions, the cumulant equation performs well, especially under low - temperature conditions. But its advantage gradually disappears under high - temperature conditions.
- **Non - Markovian effects**: The cumulant equation can better capture non - Markovian effects, especially in transient dynamics.
- **Steady - state solutions**: For the standard spin - boson model, the cumulant equation fails to fully reach the correct steady - state solution under weak - coupling conditions, but other master equations also have similar problems.
- **Lamb shift**: Lamb shift has a significant influence on the system dynamics, especially under non - Markovian conditions, and needs to be properly handled to obtain more accurate results.

### Methods

The paper uses numerically exact solutions (such as the HEOM method) as a benchmark to compare the performance of different master equations (such as the cumulant equation, Davies - GKLS equation, Bloch - Redfield equation, etc.) under different parameters. The accuracy of each method is evaluated by calculating the quantum fidelity.

### Application prospects

Because of its superior performance under weak - coupling and low - temperature conditions, the cumulant equation is considered an effective tool for simulating open quantum systems, especially when non - Markovian effects need to be considered. The simplicity and analyticity of this method make it highly practical in practical applications.