Does light slowdown in dielectric media?

Vernon Cooray,Gerald Cooray,Farhad Rachidi,Marcos Rubinstein
2024-03-05
Abstract:Observations and theoretical principles indicate that electromagnetic waves, including light, propagate in dielectric media at speeds lower than those in free space, as eloquently expressed in Maxwell's equations featuring material-dependent permittivity and permeability. This study reveals that the observed slower propagation of waves in dielectric media arises from an interference between two types of waves: a forward-moving primary wave and a set of secondary waves induced by the primary wave's interaction with the medium. The forward-moving primary wave and secondary waves travel at the speed of light in vacuum. Notably, the reflected wave caused by the impedance discontinuity on the boundary of a dielectric medium is manifested by the induced secondary waves moving in the opposite direction to the primary wave. From a photonic point of view, photons will be moving back and forth below the slowly moving apparent front of the observed wave with the speed of light in vacuum. Ahead of this front the probability of finding photons is zero due to complete destructive interference of the waves in that region. From a photonic perspective, beneath the gradually advancing facade of the observed wave, photons move at the unyielding speed of light in vacuum. The likelihood of detecting photons ahead of the front diminishes to zero, a consequence of the thorough destructive interference manifesting within that specific region.
Optics,Classical Physics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: **Does the speed of light really slow down when it propagates in a dielectric?** Specifically, the authors explored whether the propagation speed of electromagnetic waves (including light) in a dielectric is indeed lower than the speed of light in a vacuum. By analyzing the propagation process of electromagnetic waves in a dielectric, they proposed an explanation: the observed phenomenon of the decrease in the propagation speed of electromagnetic waves in a dielectric is actually due to the interference effect between the primary wave (i.e., the incident wave) and the secondary waves generated by the interaction between the primary wave and the dielectric. Among these secondary waves, some propagate forward, and others propagate backward (corresponding to the reflected wave). Although these waves themselves propagate at the speed of light in a vacuum, their interference results in an apparent wavefront whose propagation speed is lower than the speed of light. The main conclusion of the paper is that the propagation of electromagnetic waves in a dielectric can be understood as the interaction of three waves propagating at the speed of light: the primary wave, the secondary wave propagating forward, and the secondary wave propagating backward. This interaction causes the observed wavefront to move forward at a speed lower than the speed of light, and this phenomenon does not mean that the speed of a single photon is lower than the speed of light, but is caused by the interference effect of waves.