Arian Zarriz,Baptiste Journaux,Matthew J. Powell-Palm
Abstract:Phase stability, and the limits thereof, are a central concern of materials thermodynamics. However, the temperature limits of equilibrium liquid stability in chemical systems have only been widely characterized under constant (typically atmospheric) pressure conditions, whereunder the limit is represented by the eutectic. At higher pressures, this limit will shift in both temperature and chemical composition, opening a wide thermodynamic parameter space over which the absolute limit, i.e., the limit under arbitrary values of the thermodynamic forces at play (here pressure and concentration), might exist. In this work, we use isochoric freezing to measure this absolute limit for the first time in several binary aqueous brines, and, nodding to the etymology of "eutectic", we name this limit the "cenotectic" (from Greek " ", "universal-melt"). We observe that when no solute-bearing high-pressure phases exist, the cenotectic occurs consistently 22 +/- 2K below the 1 bar eutectic and at approximately 213 +/- 3 MPa, suggesting domination by the liquidus behaviors of the icy phases present. In charting the T-P evolution of each eutectic configuration, we also encounter several unreported high-pressure hydrates of NaHCO2, MgCl2, and NaCl, and we find that these high-pressure phases can produce complex multi-phase configurations involving the liquid that may remain metastable to significantly lower temperatures. We discuss the implications of these findings for ocean worlds of our solar system and cold ocean exoplanets; estimate thermodynamic limits on ice crust thickness and final ocean depth ("endgame") using the cenotectic pressure; and finally provide a generalized thermodynamic perspective on (and definition for) this fundamental thermodynamic invariant point.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the limit temperature of liquid - phase stability in aqueous solution systems under high - pressure conditions. Specifically, the paper focuses on the lowest temperature at which the liquid can remain stable in equilibrium under different pressure conditions, especially high - pressure conditions, namely the so - called "cenotectic point". This concept is an extension of the traditional "eutectic point", which is usually defined under normal pressure (such as atmospheric pressure), while the cenotectic point takes into account the liquid - phase stability limit under any pressure and concentration conditions.
### Core problems of the paper
1. **Determination of the cenotectic point**: Measure the liquid - phase stability limit, that is, the cenotectic point, of different aqueous salt solutions under high - pressure conditions through experimental measurement.
2. **Understanding the influence of high pressure on liquid - phase stability**: Explore how high pressure affects the phase diagram of aqueous solutions, especially the stability of the liquid phase.
3. **Discovery of new high - pressure phases**: Identify possible new high - pressure phases, such as new hydrate phases, during the experimental process.
### Specific research contents
- **Experimental method**: Use the isochoric freezing and melting method to measure the stability of the liquid phase under different pressure and temperature conditions.
- **Research objects**: Eight binary aqueous solutions (Na₂CO₃, KCl, MgSO₄, Na₂SO₄, urea, NaCl, MgCl₂, NaHCO₃) were selected.
- **Result analysis**: Through experimental data, the cenotectic points of six solutions were determined, and possible new high - pressure phases in the other three solutions were observed.
### Main findings
- **Measurement of the cenotectic point**: The cenotectic points of six solutions under high - pressure conditions were successfully measured, and these points represent the lowest stable temperature of the liquid phase under any pressure and concentration conditions.
- **Identification of high - pressure phases**: Possible new high - pressure phases were observed in NaCl, MgCl₂ and NaHCO₃ solutions, and these phases may represent previously undiscovered hydrates.
- **Theoretical significance**: The concept of the cenotectic point was proposed, and its applications in material thermodynamics and planetary science were discussed, especially in the study of ice - covered ocean worlds.
### Conclusion
For the first time, the paper accurately measured the cenotectic points of various binary aqueous solutions under high - pressure conditions through experimental methods, revealed the influence of high pressure on liquid - phase stability, and discovered possible new high - pressure phases. These findings not only enrich the basic knowledge of material thermodynamics but also have important significance for fields such as planetary science.