Test for Echo: X-ray Reflection Variability in the Seyfert-2 AGN NGC 4388

B. Gediman,J. M. Miller,A. Zoghbi,P. Draghis,Z. Arzoumanian,W. N . Brandt,K. Gendreau

2024-03-02

Abstract:We report on a study of the narrow Fe K$\alpha$ line and reflection spectrum in the well-known Seyfert-2 AGN, NGC 4388. X-ray spectra summed from two extensive NICER monitoring campaigns, separated by years, show strong evidence of variation in the direct continuum and reflected emission, but only small variations in the obscuring gas. Fits to the spectra from individual NICER observations find a strong, positive correlation between the power-law photon index, $\Gamma$, and direct flux that is commonly observed in unobscured AGN. A search for a reverberation lag between the direct and reflected spectra -- dominated by the narrow Fe K$\alpha$ emission line -- measures a time scale of $t = 16.37^{+0.46}_{-0.38}$ days, or a characteristic radius of $r=1.374_{-0.032}^{+0.039}\times10^{-2}$ pc $=3.4_{-0.1}^{+0.1}\times10^4\;GM/c^2$. Only one cycle of this tentative lag is observed, but it is driven by a particularly sharp drop in the direct continuum that leads to the subsequent disappearance of the otherwise prominent Fe K$\alpha$ line. Physically motivated fits to high-resolution Chandra spectra of NGC 4388 measure a line production radius of $r =2.9^{+1.2}_{-0.7}~\times 10^{4}~GM/c^{2}$, formally consistent with the tentative lag. The line profile also prefers a Compton-thick reflector, indicating an origin in the disk and/or thick clumps within a wind. We discuss the strengths and weaknesses of our analysis and methods for testing our results in future observations, and we note the potential for X-ray reverberation lags to constrain black hole masses in obscured Seyferts wherein the optical broad line region is not visible.

High Energy Astrophysical Phenomena

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper aims to explore the X - ray reflection variation phenomenon in the Seyfert - 2 active galactic nucleus NGC 4388. Specifically, the researchers focus on the changes between the direct continuum and the reflected emission of NGC 4388 in different observation periods, especially the changes of the narrow Fe Kα line. By analyzing these changes, the researchers hope to understand the geometric shape of the obscuring gas (the so - called "torus" structure) and its influence on the X - ray spectrum.

### Main problems
1. **X - ray reflection variation**: The researchers want to verify whether there is a delay phenomenon of X - ray reflection in NGC 4388. This phenomenon can provide important information about the geometric structure of the obscuring gas.
2. **Properties of the obscuring gas**: By analyzing the changes of the X - ray spectrum, the researchers hope to determine the physical properties of the obscuring gas, such as its thickness, density and distribution range.
3. **Behavior of the central engine**: The researchers also hope to understand the behavior of the central engine (i.e., the black hole and its accretion disk) by analyzing the changes of the X - ray spectrum, especially the changes on different time scales.

### Methods
- **Data sources**: The study uses the observation data of NICER and Chandra telescopes. The NICER data are divided into three observation periods, which were observed at the end of 2017 to the beginning of 2018, at the end of 2018 to the beginning of 2019, and in June 2022 respectively. The Chandra data come from two observations in 2008.
- **Spectral modeling**: The XSPEC software is used to perform spectral fitting on the NICER observation data. The models include neutral absorption, thermal plasma components, truncated power - law continuum, ionized absorption and reflection spectra, etc.
- **Variability analysis**: By comparing the spectra of different observation periods, the researchers analyzed the changes of the X - ray spectrum on long periods (several years) and short periods (several days).
- **Delay analysis**: The JAVELIN software package is used to analyze the delay phenomenon in the X - ray spectrum to verify whether there is a significant delay between the reflection spectrum and the direct continuum.

### Results
- **Long - term variability**: Over a time span of about 4.5 years, the study found that the X - ray spectrum of NGC 4388 has changed significantly, especially in the energy band above 3 keV. The flux of the direct continuum has decreased by a factor of two, and at the same time, the spectral slope has become flatter.
- **Short - term variability**: On the time scale of several days to several weeks, the study found that the variability of the X - ray spectrum is closely related to the behavior of the central engine, showing the phenomenon of "brighter and softer", that is, when the total luminosity increases, more X - rays come from the soft X - ray part.
- **Delay phenomenon**: Through JAVELIN analysis, the researchers measured a delay time of about 16.37 days, which corresponds to a characteristic radius of approximately \(3.4 \pm 0.1\times 10^4\frac{GM}{c^2}\). This result indicates that the change of the reflection spectrum lags behind that of the direct continuum, supporting the view that the reflection source is located at a farther position.

### Conclusions
This study reveals the complex geometric structure of the obscuring gas in NGC 4388 and its influence on the X - ray spectrum through detailed X - ray spectral analysis. These results are not only helpful for understanding the physical mechanisms of active galactic nuclei, but also provide important references for future research.