Human vs. Generative AI in Content Creation Competition: Symbiosis or Conflict?

Fan Yao,Chuanhao Li,Denis Nekipelov,Hongning Wang,Haifeng Xu
2024-02-24
Abstract:The advent of generative AI (GenAI) technology produces transformative impact on the content creation landscape, offering alternative approaches to produce diverse, high-quality content across media, thereby reshaping online ecosystems but also raising concerns about market over-saturation and the potential marginalization of human creativity. Our work introduces a competition model generalized from the Tullock contest to analyze the tension between human creators and GenAI. Our theory and simulations suggest that despite challenges, a stable equilibrium between human and AI-generated content is possible. Our work contributes to understanding the competitive dynamics in the content creation industry, offering insights into the future interplay between human creativity and technological advancements in GenAI.
Human-Computer Interaction,Computer Science and Game Theory
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper attempts to address the issue of exploring the competitive relationship between human creators and generative artificial intelligence (GenAI) in the field of content creation, and analyzing whether this competition will reach a stable equilibrium state. The paper introduces an extended model based on the Tullock contest model to study the tension between human creators and GenAI, and through theoretical analysis and simulation experiments, it shows that despite the challenges, it is still possible to achieve a stable equilibrium state between human-created content and AI-generated content. Specifically, the paper focuses on the following aspects: 1. **Modeling Innovation**: For the first time, a mathematical model is proposed to describe the competition between human creators and GenAI, including exclusive competition scenarios (GenAI as an exogenous influencing factor) and inclusive scenarios (each creator can independently decide whether to use GenAI tools). 2. **Conceptual Contribution**: Provides important insights into the competition between humans and AI through theory and experiments, predicting future trends in the online content market. 3. **Technical Contribution**: Not only extends the classic Tullock contest model but also derives new properties related to competitive equilibrium, enriching the theoretical advancements in the existing literature. Through this work, the paper aims to understand the future interaction patterns between human creativity and technological advancement in the content creation industry, and to explore the possible symbiotic relationship rather than antagonistic conflict between the two.