ESA Science Programme Missions: Contributions and Exploitation -- Payload Provision

John C. Zarnecki,Arvind N. Parmar

2024-02-20

Abstract:We have collected data pertaining to the Principal Investigators (PIs), and co-PIs (where appropriate) for all ESA-led Science Directorate missions since the first such launch, namely of COS-B in 1975. For a total of 28 missions (including 4 in preparation awaiting launch), 437 individuals have been recorded along with their institution, location, academic age and gender. We have correlated the number of PIs by country with the financial contribution of those countries to the ESA Science programme. We have also investigated issues associated with age and gender of the PIs. As a result of these analyses, we make suggestions for actions which ESA and its Member States may wish to consider with the aim of encouraging equity and diversity while still placing scientific excellence as the overarching goal.

Instrumentation and Methods for Astrophysics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper attempts to solve the following key problems:

1. **Analyze the contributions and fairness of various countries in ESA scientific plan missions**:
- The author collected data on principal investigators (PIs) and co - principal investigators (co - PIs) in all ESA - led scientific missions since the launch of COS - B in 1975. These data include the institutions, locations, "academic ages" and genders of PIs and co - PIs.
- By correlating the number of PIs in each country with their financial contributions to the ESA scientific plan, evaluate whether the participation of each country in scientific missions matches its financial investment.

2. **Explore the age and gender distributions of PIs and co - PIs**:
- The researchers investigated the age and gender distributions of PIs and co - PIs and analyzed how these factors affect their chances of being selected as PIs or co - PIs.
- Special attention was paid to the participation of female scientists in these missions and the trend of this participation over time.

3. **Propose improvement suggestions to promote diversity and fairness**:
- Based on the above - mentioned analysis results, the author put forward several suggestions aimed at encouraging more countries and researchers from different backgrounds to participate in ESA's scientific missions, while ensuring that scientific excellence remains the primary goal.
- These suggestions include how to increase the representation of women and other minority groups in scientific missions and how to optimize the selection process to better reflect the actual contributions of member states.

### Formula Representation

To describe certain concepts more accurately, some statistical methods and formulas are used in the paper, for example:

- **Calculation of "Academic Age"**: The year of obtaining a doctorate degree is used to approximately represent the experience levels of PIs and co - PIs.
\[
\text{Academic Age}=\text{Current Year}-\text{Year of Obtaining Doctorate Degree}
\]

- **Weighted Ratio**: To take into account the differences in complexity and scale of different tasks, a weighting factor is introduced.
\[
\text{Weighted Ratio}=\frac{\text{Actual Number of PIs and co - PIs}}{\text{Expected Number of PIs and co - PIs}}\times\text{Task Category Weight}\times\frac{1}{\text{Global Total Number of PIs and co - PIs}}
\]

Through these analyses, the author hopes to reveal some potential biases and inequalities and provide a basis for future improvements.