Metaverse Perspectives from Japan: A Participatory Speculative Design Case Study

Michel Hohendanner,Chiara Ullstein,Dohjin Miyamoto,Emma Fukuwatari Huffman,Gudrun Socher,Jens Grossklags,Hirotaka Osawa

2024-01-31

Abstract:Currently, the development of the metaverse lies in the hands of industry. Citizens have little influence on this process. Instead, to do justice to the pluralism of (digital) societies, we should strive for an open discourse including many different perspectives on the metaverse and its core technologies such as AI. We utilize a participatory speculative design (PSD) approach to explore Japanese citizens' perspectives on future metaverse societies, as well as social and ethical implications. Our contributions are twofold. Firstly, we demonstrate the effectiveness of PSD in engaging citizens in critical discourse on emerging technologies like the metaverse, offering our workshop framework as a methodological contribution. Secondly, we identify key themes from participants' perspectives, providing insights for culturally sensitive design and development of virtual environments. Our analysis shows that participants imagine the metaverse to have the potential to solve a variety of societal issues; for example, breaking down barriers of physical environments for communication, social interaction, crisis preparation, and political participation, or tackling identity-related issues. Regarding future metaverse societies, participants' imaginations raise critical questions about human-AI relations, technical solutionism, politics and technology, globalization and local cultures, and immersive technologies. We discuss implications and contribute to expanding conversations on metaverse developments.

Computers and Society,Human-Computer Interaction

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper attempts to address the following key issues:

1. **Exploring Japanese citizens' views on the future metaverse society and its socio-ethical impacts**: Through the Participatory Speculative Design (PSD) method, the study investigates Japanese citizens' perspectives on the future metaverse society and the socio-ethical impacts of related technologies.

2. **Demonstrating the effectiveness of the PSD method**: Proving that PSD, as a methodological tool, is effective in promoting critical public discussions on emerging technologies such as the metaverse, and providing a workshop framework as a methodological contribution.

3. **Identifying key themes**: Identifying key themes from the participants' perspectives to provide insights for culturally sensitive design and virtual environment development. The analysis shows that participants believe the metaverse has the potential to address various social issues, such as breaking physical barriers in communication, social interaction, crisis preparedness, and political participation, as well as addressing identity-related issues.

4. **Provoking critical thinking on human-AI relationships and other issues**: Participants' visions of the metaverse raised key questions about human-machine relationships, technological solutionism, politics and technology, globalization and local culture, and immersive technologies.

In summary, this study aims to enrich the dialogue on metaverse development by introducing the citizens' perspective and emphasizes the necessity of considering citizen-centric and local cultural sensitivity in the research, design, and development of the future metaverse.