Competing magnetic states on the surface of multilayer ABC-stacked graphene

Lauro B. Braz,Tanay Nag,Annica M. Black-Schaffer

2024-01-30

Abstract:We study interaction-mediated magnetism on the surface of ABC-multilayer graphene driven by its zero-energy topological flat bands. Using the random-phase approximation we treat onsite Hubbard repulsion and find multiple competing magnetic states, due to both intra- and inter-valley scattering, with the latter causing an enlarged magnetic unit cell. At half-filling and when the Hubbard repulsion is weak, we observe two different ferromagnetic orders. Once the Hubbard repulsion becomes more realistic, new ferrimagnetic orders arise with distinct incommensurate intra- or inter-valley scattering vectors depending on interaction strength and doping, leading to a multitude of competing magnetic states.

Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics,Strongly Correlated Electrons

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to understand the magnetic state on the surface of ABC - stacked multilayer graphene (ABC - MLG). Specifically, the authors studied the interaction - mediated magnetism driven by zero - energy topological flat bands and explored various competing magnetic states that may emerge under different interaction strengths and doping levels.

### Main problems
1. **Origin of magnetism**: Investigate whether the magnetism on the ABC - MLG surface can be induced by its zero - energy topological flat bands.
2. **Competition of magnetic states**: Analyze which magnetic states will dominate under different conditions (such as Hubbard repulsion strength, doping level, etc.).
3. **Diversity of magnetic patterns**: Reveal the changes in magnetic patterns (such as ferromagnetic, ferrimagnetic) and their corresponding scattering vectors in the cases of half - filling and non - half - filling.

### Research methods
- **Model construction**: Use the tight - binding model to describe the electronic structure of ABC - MLG and introduce the on - site Coulomb repulsion term \(U\) in the Hubbard model to simulate the interaction between electrons.
- **Calculation method**: Adopt the T - matrix form to isolate the surface Green's function and combine the random - phase approximation (RPA) to handle electron - electron interactions, thereby calculating the spin susceptibility matrix \(\hat{\chi}_s(q,\omega)\).
- **Analysis means**: By analyzing the real and imaginary parts of spin susceptibility, determine the magnetic states that may be formed under different conditions and explore the spatial structures and dynamic characteristics of these states.

### Key findings
- **At half - filling**: Under weak interactions, two different ferromagnetic orders were found; while under more realistic interaction strengths, a new ferrimagnetic order emerged, with different incommensurate scattering vectors.
- **At non - half - filling**: As the doping level increases, the magnetic state transforms into another set of incommensurate ferrimagnetic orders, and these states exhibit a significantly shortened spin - spin relaxation time.
- **Competition mechanism**: The research shows that there is intense competition among multiple magnetic states under different interaction strengths and doping levels, especially the competition involving inter - valley and intra - valley scattering.

### Conclusion
This research reveals the rich magnetic possibilities on the ABC - MLG surface, including competing inter - valley and intra - valley scattering states, and different magnetic states that vary with interactions and doping. These results provide an important theoretical basis for understanding the magnetism of multilayer graphene and offer guidance for further experimental verification.

Through the above research, the authors not only explained the complexity of the magnetism on the ABC - MLG surface but also demonstrated potential ways to regulate these magnetic states, providing a valuable reference for future research and applications.