Uncertainty quantification of receptor ligand binding sites prediction

Nanjie Chen,Dongliang Yu,Dmitri Beglov,Mark Kon,Julio Enrique Castrillon-Candas

2024-01-24

Abstract:Recent advancements in protein docking site prediction have highlighted the limitations of traditional rigid docking algorithms, like PIPER, which often neglect critical stochastic elements such as solvent-induced fluctuations. These oversights can lead to inaccuracies in identifying viable docking sites due to the complexity of high-dimensional, stochastic energy manifolds with low regularity. To address this issue, our research introduces a novel model where the molecular shapes of ligands and receptors are represented using multi-variate Karhunen-Lo `eve (KL) expansions. This method effectively captures the stochastic nature of energy manifolds, allowing for a more accurate representation of molecular interactions.Developed as a plugin for PIPER, our scientific computing software enhances the platform, delivering robust uncertainty measures for the energy manifolds of ranked binding sites. Our results demonstrate that top-ranked binding sites, characterized by lower uncertainty in the stochastic energy manifold, align closely with actual docking sites. Conversely, sites with higher uncertainty correlate with less optimal docking positions. This distinction not only validates our approach but also sets a new standard in protein docking predictions, offering substantial implications for future molecular interaction research and drug development.

Quantitative Methods

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper mainly focuses on the quantification of uncertainty in protein receptor-ligand binding site prediction. Traditional rigid docking algorithms, such as PIPER, may result in inaccurate binding site prediction due to the neglect of key random factors like molecular shape fluctuations caused by solvents. To address this issue, the researchers proposed a new model that uses multivariate Karhunen-Loève (KL) expansion to represent the molecular shapes of ligands and receptors. This method can effectively capture the stochastic nature of energy manifolds, thereby providing a more accurate description of molecular interactions. The paper developed a plugin software integrated with the PIPER platform to provide a measure of uncertainty for energy manifolds. The results showed that binding sites with lower uncertainty of energy manifolds ranked closer to the actual binding sites, while sites with higher uncertainty corresponded to less ideal binding positions. This approach not only validated the effectiveness of the new method but also set new standards for future molecular interaction studies and drug development. In the study, the authors pointed out the limitations of rigid docking methods and introduced flexible docking, which considers molecular flexibility and solvent effects. They proposed a framework that models molecular shapes as random fields to better handle solvent-induced shape uncertainty. Through Karhunen-Loève expansion, they were able to quantify the uncertainty of molecular shapes while maintaining computational efficiency. The paper concluded with the discussion of experiments and results, demonstrating how this method can be used to analyze the impact of solvent uncertainty on binding site prediction and providing empirical evidence to support the accuracy of their approach. Through this method, they were able to identify the uncertainty of binding sites, providing a basis for optimizing docking predictions.

Uncertainty quantification of receptor ligand binding sites prediction

Uni-Mol Docking V2: Towards Realistic and Accurate Binding Pose Prediction

Higher Accuracy Achieved for Protein-Ligand Binding Pose Prediction by Elastic Network Model-Based Ensemble Docking.

Synergistic Application of Molecular Docking and Machine Learning for Improved Binding Pose

DeltaDock: A Unified Framework for Accurate, Efficient, and Physically Reliable Molecular Docking

Predicting Protein-Ligand Binding Sites Based on an Improved Geometric Algorithm

Scrutinization on Docking Against Individually Generated Target Pockets for Each Ligand

Re-Dock: Towards Flexible and Realistic Molecular Docking with Diffusion Bridge

DOX: A New Computational Protocol for Accurate Prediction of the Protein-Ligand Binding Structures.

An integrated approach to protein-protein docking

Integrating Quantum Mechanics into Protein-Ligand Docking: Toward Higher Accuracy and Reliability

A-RFP: An Adaptive Residue Flexibility Prediction Method Improving Protein-ligand Docking Based on Homologous Proteins

EDock: blind protein-ligand docking by replica-exchange monte carlo simulation

Comprehensive Assessment of Flexible-Ligand Docking Algorithms: Current Effectiveness and Challenges

Docking Challenge: Protein Sampling and Molecular Docking Performance

Protein-protein docking with interface residue restraints*

Bayesian active learning for optimization and uncertainty quantification in protein docking

CDOCKER and $$\Lambda$$-Dynamics for Prospective Prediction in D3R Grand Challenge 2

Inclusion of the Orientational Entropic Effect and Low-Resolution Experimental Information for Protein-Protein Docking in Critical Assessment of PRedicted Interactions (CAPRI).

Combining Classical Molecular Docking with Self-Consistent Charge Density-Functional Tight-Binding Computations for the Efficient and Quality Prediction of Ligand Binding Structure

Multi-scale Iterative Refinement towards Robust and Versatile Molecular Docking