Partition-form Cooperative Games in Two-Echelon Supply Chains

Gurkirat Wadhwa,Tushar Shankar Walunj,Veeraruna Kavitha
DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2401.04939
2024-01-10
Abstract:Competition and cooperation are inherent features of any multi-echelon supply chain. The interactions among the agents across the same echelon and that across various echelons influence the percolation of market demand across echelons. The agents may want to collaborate with others in pursuit of attracting higher demand and thereby improving their own revenue. We consider one supplier (at a higher echelon) and two manufacturers (at a lower echelon and facing the customers) and study the collaborations that are `stable'; the main differentiator from the existing studies in supply chain literature is the consideration of the following crucial aspect -- the revenue of any collaborative unit also depends upon the way the opponents collaborate. Such competitive scenarios can be modeled using what is known as partition form games. Our study reveals that the grand coalition is not stable when the product is essential and the customers buy it from any of the manufacturers without a preference. The supplier prefers to collaborate with only one manufacturer, the one stronger in terms of market power; further, such collaboration is stable only when the stronger manufacturer is significantly stronger. Interestingly, no stable collaborative arrangements exist when the two manufacturers are nearly equal in market power.
Theoretical Economics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is how the cooperation and competition between suppliers and manufacturers and among manufacturers in a two - tier supply chain affect market demand transfer and profit distribution. Specifically, by constructing a partition - based cooperative game model, the paper explores which cooperation forms are stable in a two - tier supply chain consisting of a supplier and two manufacturers, especially when the product is a necessity for consumers. The study finds that when the product is a necessity and consumers have no preference for manufacturers, overall cooperation (i.e., the grand coalition) is not stable. The supplier tends to cooperate only with one manufacturer with stronger market power, and this cooperation is stable only when the stronger manufacturer is significantly powerful. When the two manufacturers are similar in market power, there is no stable cooperation arrangement. In addition, the paper also explores pricing strategies and profit distribution issues under different cooperation models, and how these strategies affect stability and efficiency in the supply chain.