Abstract:In this article, we study conditions of continuous emergent symmetries in gapless states, either as topological quantum critical points (TQCPs) or a stable phase with protecting symmetries and connections to smooth deformations of the gapped states around. We illustrate that for a wide class of gapless states that can be associated with fully-isolated scale invariant fixed points, there shall always be emergent continuous symmetries that are directly related to smooth deformations of gapped states with symmetries lower than the protecting ones $G_p$. For a 3D TQCP in DIII classes with $G_p=Z^T_2$, $U_{EM}=U(1)$ and $N_f=\frac{1}{2}$ fermions but without charge $U(1)$ symmetry, we explicitly construct a corresponding boundary representation based on a $4D$ topological state with lattice symmetry $H=Z^T_2 \ltimes U(1)$ and $N_f={1}$ fermions. Although emergent continuous symmetries appear to be robust at weakly interacting TQCPs, we further show the breakdown of such one-to-one correspondence between deformations of gapped states and emergent continuous symmetries when gapless states become strongly interacting. In a strongly interacting limit, gapless states can be represented by a smooth manifold of conformal-field-theory fixed points rather than a fully isolated one. A smooth manifold of strong coupling fixed points hinders emergence of a continuous emergent symmetry in the strongly interacting gapless limit, as deformations no longer leave a gapless state or a TQCP invariant, unlike in the more conventional weakly interacting case. This typically reduces continuous emergent symmetries to a discrete symmetry originating from duality transformations under the protection symmetry $G_p$.

Constructing a weakly-interacting fixed point of the Fermionic Polchinski equation

Constructing a weakly-interacting fixed point of the Fermionic Polchinski equation

Fermionic fixed-point structure of asymptotically safe QED with a Pauli term

Non-Fermi Liquid Fixed Point in 2 + 1 Dimensions

Functional renormalization group approach to dipolar fixed point which is scale-invariant but non-conformal

Non-trivial fixed point of a $ψ^4_d$ fermionic theory, II. Anomalous exponent and scaling operators

Scalar-Fermion Fixed Points in the $\varepsilon$ Expansion

The fixed point action for the Schwinger model: a perturbative approach

Intermittency generated by attracting and weakly repelling fixed points

Construction of Gross-Neveu model using Polchinski flow equation

Construction of Quantum Field Theories with Factorizing S-Matrices

Non-Fermi Liquid Behavior in 3+1 Dimensions with PT Invariant Gauge Field: An Renormalization Group Approach

Renormalization Flow of Nonlinear Electrodynamics

Continuous Renormalization for Fermions and Fermi Liquid Theory

Bound states for Overlap and Fixed Point Actions close to the chiral limit

The Wilson-Fisher Fixed point revisited: importance of the form of the cutoff

Perturbative Construction of Equilibrium States for Interacting Fermionic Field Theories

Emergent symmetries and Interactions: An isolated fixed point Vs a manifold of strongly interacting fixed points

Effective potential, renormalization, and nontrivial ultraviolet fixed point in D-dimensional four-fermion theories (24) to order 1N in 1N expansion

Fixed Points of Quantum Gravity from Dimensional Regularisation