Abstract:This article extends, in a stochastic setting, previous results in the determination of feasible exchange ratios for merging companies. A first outcome is that shareholders of the companies involved in the merging process face both an upper and a lower bounds for acceptable exchange ratios. Secondly, in order for the improved `bargaining region' to be intelligibly displayed, the diagrammatic approach developed by Kulpa is exploited.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: during the corporate merger process, how to determine a reasonable exchange ratio (ER) so that the merged company can both increase the expected wealth of shareholders and reduce risks in an uncertain market environment. Specifically, the paper extends the Larson - Gonedes and Yagil (referred to as LG - Y for short) model, introduces randomness, and shows the feasible exchange ratio interval through graphical methods.
### Main problem decomposition:
1. **Determine the upper and lower limits of the exchange ratio**:
- In a deterministic framework, the LG - Y model has already provided a feasible interval (Bargaining Region, BR) for the exchange ratio, that is, all exchange ratios that do not reduce shareholder wealth.
- This paper further extends this result in a stochastic environment, taking into account the randomness of stock prices and changes in risks.
2. **Introduce risk measures**:
- In a stochastic environment, it is necessary to consider not only the expected changes in equity value but also changes in risks. For this purpose, the article introduces a risk - measurement function to evaluate the risk impact of the merger on shareholders.
3. **Application of graphical methods**:
- In order to more intuitively show these complex interval relationships, the article adopts Kulpa's graphical representation method, converting intervals into points on a two - dimensional plane, thereby simplifying understanding.
### Specific objectives:
- **Clarify the upper and lower limits of the exchange ratio**: Ensure that the exchange ratio acceptable to the shareholders of the merged company neither reduces their expected wealth nor increases their risks.
- **Provide an intuitive graphical representation**: Show the feasible exchange ratio interval through graphical methods to help decision - makers better understand the impacts of different merger plans.
### Summary of mathematical formulas:
- Formulas for the upper and lower limits of the exchange ratio:
\[
r_{\mu}(\mu_M)=\frac{\mu_M - \mu_A}{\mu_B}
\]
\[
r_{\rho}(\rho_M)=\frac{\rho_M - \rho_A}{\rho_B}
\]
- Risk - adjusted exchange ratio:
\[
r^*=\frac{p_B}{p_A}, \quad r^{**}=\frac{\phi_B}{\phi_A}
\]
- Definition of the consistency region (Consistency Region, CR):
\[
CRA(\mu_M,\rho_M)=\left[ r_{\rho}(\rho_M), r_{\mu}(\mu_M)\right]
\]
\[
CRB(\mu_M,\rho_M)=\left[ r_{\mu}(\mu_M), r_{\rho}(\rho_M)\right]
\]
Through these formulas and graphical methods, the article aims to provide a more comprehensive and intuitive analysis framework for determining the exchange ratio during the corporate merger process.