The Stanley Conjecture Revisited

Ryan Mickler

2024-01-14

Abstract:In the seminal work of Stanley, several conjectures were made on the structure of Littlewood-Richardson coefficients for the multiplication of Jack symmetric functions. Motivated by recent results of Alexandersson and the present author, we postulate that a certain 'windowing' property holds for all such Jack L-R coefficients. This property provides a vast set of relations between these coefficients and allows for their direct computation in certain novel cases. We demonstrate compatibility between our windowing conjecture and the conjectures of Stanley, with the hope of illuminating the structures within.

Combinatorics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is about the structure of Jack Littlewood - Richardson (LR) coefficients and their calculation methods. Specifically, the main objective of the paper is to propose and verify a "Windowing Property", which provides a new way to understand and calculate Jack LR coefficients and is compatible with the conjecture proposed by Stanley in 1989. The following are the specific problems that the paper attempts to solve:

1. **Structure of Jack LR coefficients**:
- The paper attempts to provide a series of relationships between Jack LR coefficients by proposing the "Windowing Property". This property allows for the direct calculation of these coefficients in some new situations, thus providing a new perspective for understanding the structure of Jack LR coefficients.

2. **Compatibility with Stanley's conjecture**:
- The paper explores the compatibility between the "Windowing Property" and Stanley's conjecture, especially with Stanley's Strong Stanley Conjecture. Stanley's Strong Stanley Conjecture proposes the specific form of Jack LR coefficients when the Schur LR coefficient \( c_{\lambda}^{\mu\nu}=1 \).

3. **New calculation method**:
- Through the "Windowing Property", the paper proposes a new method for calculating Jack LR coefficients. Especially in some specific cases, such as in the case of Rectangular Union, this method can simplify the calculation process.

4. **Proof path**:
- The paper optimistically believes that if the proposed "Windowing Property" and other related conjectures are proven to be correct, then they may provide a potential path for proving Stanley's conjecture.

### Mathematical formulation of specific problems

- **Definition of Jack LR coefficients**:
\[
J_\mu\cdot J_\nu=\sum_{\lambda}g_{\lambda}^{\mu\nu}J_\lambda
\]
where \( J_\mu \) and \( J_\nu \) are Jack symmetric functions, and \( g_{\lambda}^{\mu\nu} \) is the Jack Littlewood - Richardson coefficient.

- **Stanley's conjecture**:
- **Weak form**: The Jack LR coefficient \( g_{\lambda}^{\mu\nu} \) is the ratio of non - negative integer polynomials \( \alpha \), that is, \( g_{\lambda}^{\mu\nu}\cdot j_\lambda\in\mathbb{Z}_{\geq 0}[\alpha] \).
- **Strong form**: When \( c_{\lambda}^{\mu\nu} = 1 \), the form of the Jack LR coefficient is:
\[
g_{\lambda}^{\mu\nu}=\frac{\prod_{b\in\mu}h_{\Phi_b^\mu}(b)\prod_{b\in\nu}h_{\Phi_b^\nu}(b)}{\prod_{b\in\lambda}h_{\Phi_b^\lambda}(b)}
\]
where \( \Phi_b \) is the choice on each square \( b \), which can be an upper hook \( U \) or a lower hook \( L \).

- **Windowing property**:
- The paper proposes a more general structural conjecture, that is, for any \( \mu, \nu, \lambda \), there exist channel coefficients \( c_\Phi\in\mathbb{Z} \) such that:
\[
g_{\lambda}^{\mu\nu}=\sum_{\Phi\in H_{\l}