The Influence of Biomedical Research on Future Business Funding: Analyzing Scientific Impact and Content in Industrial Investments

Reza Khanmohammadi,Simerjot Kaur,Charese H. Smiley,Tuka Alhanai,Ivan Brugere,Armineh Nourbakhsh,Mohammad M. Ghassemi

2024-01-02

Abstract:This paper investigates the relationship between scientific innovation in biomedical sciences and its impact on industrial activities, focusing on how the historical impact and content of scientific papers influenced future funding and innovation grant application content for small businesses. The research incorporates bibliometric analyses along with SBIR (Small Business Innovation Research) data to yield a holistic view of the science-industry interface. By evaluating the influence of scientific innovation on industry across 10,873 biomedical topics and taking into account their taxonomic relationships, we present an in-depth exploration of science-industry interactions where we quantify the temporal effects and impact latency of scientific advancements on industrial activities, spanning from 2010 to 2021. Our findings indicate that scientific progress substantially influenced industrial innovation funding and the direction of industrial innovation activities. Approximately 76% and 73% of topics showed a correlation and Granger-causality between scientific interest in papers and future funding allocations to relevant small businesses. Moreover, around 74% of topics demonstrated an association between the semantic content of scientific abstracts and future grant applications. Overall, the work contributes to a more nuanced and comprehensive understanding of the science-industry interface, opening avenues for more strategic resource allocation and policy developments aimed at fostering innovation.

Computational Engineering, Finance, and Science

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### Problems the Paper Attempts to Solve

This paper aims to explore the impact of biomedical science research on industrial activities, particularly how the influence and content of historical scientific papers affect future small business funding allocation and innovation grant applications. Specifically, the study provides a comprehensive view of the science-industry interface by combining bibliometric analysis and Small Business Innovation Research (SBIR) data. The main objectives of the study include:

1. **Can the impact of historical scientific papers serve as a leading indicator for future related small business funding allocation?**
- By analyzing the citation counts of historical scientific papers on specific biomedical topics, the study investigates whether the influence of these papers can predict future small business funding allocation in the same field.

2. **Can the content of historical scientific abstracts serve as a leading indicator for future small business innovation grant applications?**
- By analyzing the semantic content of historical scientific abstracts on specific biomedical topics, the study explores whether these abstracts can predict the content of future small business innovation grant applications in the same field.

### Research Background

The impact of scientific innovation on industrial activities is particularly significant in the fields of biomedical and health sciences, where scientific validation is often a prerequisite for commercial translation. For example, the development of CRISPR-Cas9 technology demonstrates how scientific innovation can guide the direction of industrial activities. However, the extent and timescale of the impact of scientific innovation on downstream industrial activities vary significantly across different research topics, influenced by complex factors such as government regulation, economic conditions, and social perception. Currently, there is a lack of detailed characterization of the impact of scientific activities on downstream industrial activities, and filling this gap is the main research objective of this paper.

### Research Significance

Understanding the relationship between scientific innovation and industrial activities has important practical significance. Identifying scientific fields with significant industrial impact can help companies anticipate future trends and adjust their investment strategies. Similarly, researchers who understand the commercial impact of their research are more likely to conduct research with high translational potential. For example, understanding the industrial relevance of developing more effective antibiotics can guide biomedical researchers to focus on this field, thereby improving public health outcomes and creating economic growth opportunities for the pharmaceutical industry.

### Research Methods

1. **Data Sources**:
- **PubMed**: Collected abstracts and metadata of 10,928,078 scientific publications from 2010 to 2021.
- **SBIR**: Collected project abstracts and grant amounts of 63,488 Small Business Innovation Research (SBIR) grants from 2010 to 2021.

2. **Topic Classification**:
- Used the Medical Subject Headings (MeSH) to classify biomedical topics. MeSH is a controlled and hierarchically organized vocabulary maintained by the United States National Library of Medicine for indexing, cataloging, and searching biomedical and health-related information.

3. **Data Analysis**:
- **Representation of Scientific Activities**: Represented scientific activities by the normalized annual number of published papers and citation counts.
- **Representation of Industrial Activities**: Represented industrial activities by the normalized annual number of SBIR grants and cumulative grant amounts.
- **Trend Correlation Measurement**: Used cross-correlation analysis to measure the time-lag relationship between scientific activities and industrial activities.
- **Causality Measurement**: Used Granger causality to assess whether scientific activities can predict future industrial activities.

### Main Contributions

1. **Extensive Evaluation of Biomedical Research Topics**: Explored the impact of scientific innovation on industrial activities across 10,873 biomedical topics, making it the most comprehensive exploration to date.
2. **Consideration of Topic Classification Relationships**: Analyzed the classification relationships and hierarchies of topics, clarifying the impact of scientific innovation on specific industrial activities (e.g., CRISPR-Cas9) or broader industrial trends (e.g., genetic phenomena).
3. **Assessment of Time Effects and Impact Delays**: Analyzed the temporal evolution and delays of the impact of scientific innovation on industrial activities from 2010 to 2021.
4. **Diverse Analytical Methods**: Employed correlation and causality studies, as well as overlap analysis of scientific and industrial text content, to understand the connection between science and industry from multiple perspectives.

Through these methods, the study aims to provide a more comprehensive understanding, bridging the gap between scientific innovation and industrial application.