NanoNewton electrostatic force actuators for femtoNewton-sensitive measurements: system performance test in the LISA Pathfinder mission

M Armano,H Audley,J Baird,M Bassan,P Binetruy,M Born,D Bortoluzzi,E Castelli,A Cavalleri,A Cesarini,V Chiavegato,A M Cruise,D Dal Bosco,K Danzmann,M De Deus Silva,R De Rosa,L Di Fiore,I Diepholz,G Dixon,R Dolesi,L Ferraioli V Ferroni,E D Fitzsimons,M Freschi,L Gesa,D Giardini,F Gibert,R Giusteri,A Grado,C Grimani,J Grzymisch,I Harrison,M S Hartig,G Heinzel,M Hewitson,D Hollington,D Hoyland,M Hueller,H Inchauspé,O Jennrich,P Jetzer,B Johlander,N Karnesis,B Kaune,N Korsakova,C J Killow,L Liu,J A Lobo,J P López-Zaragoza,R Maarschalkerweerd,D Mance,V Martín,L Martin-Polo,F Martin-Porqueras,J Martino,P W McNamara,J Mendes,L Mendes,N Meshksar,J Moerschell,M Nofrarias,S Paczkowski,M Perreur-Lloyd,A Petiteau,E Plagnol,C Praplan,J Ramos-Castro,J Reiche,F Rivas,D I Robertson,G Russano,L Sala,P Sarra,S L Schule-Walewski,J Slutsky,C F Sopuerta,R Stanga,T Sumner,J ten Pierick,D Texier,J I Thorpe,D Vetrugno,S Vitale,G Wanner,H Ward,P Wass,W J Weber,L Wissel,A Wittchen,C Zanoni,P Zweifel
2023-12-30
Abstract:Electrostatic force actuation is a key component of the system of geodesic reference test masses (TM) for the LISA orbiting gravitational wave observatory and in particular for performance at low frequencies, below 1 mHz, where the observatory sensitivity is limited by stray force noise. The system needs to apply forces of order 10$^{-9}$ N while limiting fluctuations in the measurement band to levels approaching 10$^{-15}$ N/Hz$^{1/2}$. We present here the LISA actuation system design, based on audio-frequency voltage carrier signals, and results of its in-flight performance test with the LISA Pathfinder test mission. In LISA, TM force actuation is used to align the otherwise free-falling TM to the spacecraft-mounted optical metrology system, without any forcing along the critical gravitational wave-sensitive interferometry axes. In LISA Pathfinder, on the other hand, the actuation was used also to stabilize the TM along the critical $x$ axis joining the two TM, with the commanded actuation force entering directly into the mission's main differential acceleration science observable. The mission allowed demonstration of the full compatibility of the electrostatic actuation system with the LISA observatory requirements, including dedicated measurement campaigns to amplify, isolate, and quantify the two main force noise contributions from the actuation system, from actuator gain noise and from low frequency ``in band'' voltage fluctuations. These campaigns have shown actuation force noise to be a relevant, but not dominant, noise source in LISA Pathfinder and have allowed performance projections for the conditions expected in the LISA mission.
Instrumentation and Methods for Astrophysics,General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper attempts to address the problem of how to achieve a high-precision electrostatic force actuation system in the LISA (Laser Interferometer Space Antenna) Pathfinder mission to meet the requirements for low-frequency (below 1 mHz) gravitational wave observations. Specifically, the paper focuses on how to design and test an electrostatic force actuation system capable of applying forces at the nano-Newton (nN) level and limiting in-band measurement noise to the femto-Newton (fN) level. ### Background LISA Pathfinder is a space experiment aimed at validating key technologies for the future LISA mission. LISA will observe low-frequency gravitational waves in space, and one of the main objectives of LISA Pathfinder is to test and validate the electrostatic force actuation system used to control the test masses (TMs). These test masses need to be kept in a nearly free-fall state to minimize the impact of external disturbance forces, thereby improving the sensitivity of gravitational wave signal detection. ### Core Issues 1. **Low-Frequency Force Noise**: In the low-frequency range (< 1 mHz), LISA's sensitivity is limited by stray force noise. Therefore, it is necessary to design an electrostatic force actuation system capable of applying forces at the nano-Newton level and limiting noise to the femto-Newton level. 2. **Force Control Precision**: The electrostatic force actuation system needs to precisely control the position and attitude of the test masses to ensure their relative position in space remains stable. 3. **System Performance Validation**: The system's performance needs to be validated under actual flight conditions, including the sources and levels of force noise, as well as the system's stability and reliability. ### Solution The paper details the design, implementation, and test results of the electrostatic force actuation system used in the LISA Pathfinder mission. Specifically, it includes: - **Design Features**: Using audio frequency voltage carrier signals (60-270 Hz) to generate the required DC and slowly varying electrostatic forces to avoid low-frequency noise caused by stray electric fields. - **Circuit Implementation**: Ensuring the stability and accuracy of the electrostatic force actuation system through multi-stage RC filters and digital signal processing techniques. - **Performance Testing**: Detailed performance tests were conducted during the LISA Pathfinder mission, including quantifying force noise and calibrating the system. ### Experimental Results - **Force Noise Quantification**: Through dedicated measurement activities, two main sources of force noise were quantified: drive gain fluctuations and low-frequency additive voltage noise. - **System Calibration**: Through system identification experiments, the gain factors and stiffness coefficients of the force actuation system were calibrated to ensure the system's accuracy and stability. - **Performance Validation**: Experimental results show that the electrostatic force actuation system meets the requirements of the LISA mission, particularly achieving the expected target for force noise levels in the low-frequency range. ### Conclusion The paper validates the performance of the electrostatic force actuation system in the LISA Pathfinder mission through detailed design and testing, providing important technical support for future LISA missions. These results not only verify the feasibility of the system but also lay the foundation for future low-frequency gravitational wave observations.