Abstract:As evidence mounts that the cardiac-sympathetic nervous system reacts to challenging cognitive settings, we ask if these responses are epiphenomenal companions or if there is evidence suggesting a more intertwined role of this system with cognitive function. Healthy male and female human participants performed an approach-avoidance paradigm, trading off monetary reward for painful electric shock, while we recorded simultaneous electroencephalographic (EEG) and cardiac-sympathetic signals. Participants were reward sensitive, but also experienced approach-avoidance "conflict" when the subjective appeal of the reward was near equivalent to the revulsion of the cost. Drift-diffusion model parameters suggested that participants managed conflict in part by integrating larger volumes of evidence into choices (wider decision boundaries). Late alpha-band (neural) dynamics were consistent with widening decision boundaries serving to combat reward-sensitivity and spread attention more fairly to all dimensions of available information. Independently, wider boundaries were also associated with cardiac "contractility" (an index of sympathetically mediated positive inotropy). We also saw evidence of conflict-specific "collaboration" between the neural and cardiac-sympathetic signals. In states of high conflict, the alignment (i.e., product) of alpha dynamics and contractility were associated with a further widening of the boundary, independent of either signal's singular association. Cross-trial coherence analyses provided additional evidence that the autonomic systems controlling cardiac-sympathetics might influence the assessment of information streams during conflict by disrupting or overriding reward processing. We conclude that cardiac-sympathetic control might play a critical role, in collaboration with cognitive processes, during the approach-avoidance conflict in humans.Significance statement Complex behavior likely involves coordination across multiple branches of the human nervous system. We know much of how cortical systems of the brain adapt to cognitive challenges. In parallel, we are beginning to understand that autonomic mediated responses in peripheral organ (cardiac-sympathetic) systems might also play an adaptive role in cognition, particularly complex decisions. We probed if such signals have separate or collaborative associations with behavior, using computational models of decision behavior, brain (electroencephalography) and cardiac-sympathetic (contractility) data. Our evidence suggests that these systems might work together, as humans attend to all available information when resolving particularly conflicting decisions. The cardiac-sympathetic system may be part of a coordinated response that helps balance the human tendency to overly focus on rewards.

Enhanced cardiac perception is associated with increased susceptibility to framing effects

A Study on the Celebral Hemisphere Positioning of Processing for the Framing Effect

Is the framing effect a framing affect?

Thinking Fast Increases Framing Effects in Risky Decision Making

Deep thoughts and shallow frames: on the susceptibility to framing effects

Social Risky Decision-Making Reveals Gender Differences in the TPJ: A Hyperscanning Study Using Functional Near-Infrared Spectroscopy

Framing Effects in Intertemporal Choices: 3 Two‐Step Experiments

Influence of Negative Emotion on the Framing Effect

Brain Potentials Associated with the Outcome Processing in Framing Effects.

Is alexithymia characterised by impaired interoception? Further evidence, the importance of control variables, and the problems with the Heartbeat Counting Task

A hierarchical Bayesian model reveals increased precision weighting for afferent cardiac signals, and reduced anxiety, as a function of interoceptive training

Neural basis of emotional decision making in trait anxiety

Time to Pay Attention? Information Search Explains Amplified Framing Effects Under Time Pressure

Social interoception: Perceiving events during cardiac afferent activity makes people more suggestible to other people's influence

Interoceptive Signals Bias Decision Making in Rhesus Macaques

Sensitivity to changes in rate of heartbeats as a measure of interoceptive ability.

Cardiac-sympathetic contractility and neural alpha-band power: cross-modal collaboration during approach-avoidance conflict

Emotion-induced loss aversion and striatal-amygdala coupling in low-anxious individuals

Why it is good to communicate the bad: understanding the influence of message framing in persuasive communication on consumer decision-making processes

AFFECT AND THE FRAMING EFFECT WITHIN INDIVIDUALS OVER TIME: RISK TAKING IN A DYNAMIC INVESTMENT SIMULATION

The Increasing Effect of Interoception on Brain Frontal Responsiveness During a Socially Framed Motor Synchronization Task