Evaluating the portable X-ray fluorescence reliability for metal(loid)s detection and soil contamination status
Alqattan, Zain Alabdain,Artiola, Janick F.,Walls, Dan,Ramírez-Andreotta, Mónica D.
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10661-024-12893-8
IF: 3.307
2024-07-30
Environmental Monitoring and Assessment
Abstract:Marginalized communities experience barriers that can prevent soil monitoring efforts and knowledge transfer. To address this challenge, this study compared two analytical methods: portable X-ray fluorescence spectroscopy (pXRF, less time, cost) and inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS, "gold standard"). Surface soil samples were collected from residential sites in Arizona, USA ( N = 124) and public areas in Troy, New York, USA ( N = 33). Soil preparation differed between groups to account for community practice. Statistical calculations were conducted, paired t test, Bland–Altman plot, and a two-way ANOVA indicated no significant difference for As, Ba, Ca, Cu, Mn, Pb, and Zn concentrations except for Ba in the t test. Iron, Ni, Cr, and K were statistically different for Arizona soils and V, Ni, Fe, and Al concentrations were statistically different for New York soils. Zinc was the only element with high R 2 and low p value. Pollution load index (PLI), enrichment factors (EF), and geo-accumulation index (I geo ) were calculated for both methods using U.S. Geological Survey data. The PLI were > 1, indicating soil pollution in the two states. Between pXRF and ICP-MS, the I geo and EF in Arizona had similar degree of contamination for most elements except Zn in garden and Pb in yard, respectively. For New York, the I geo of As, Cu, and Zn differed by only one classification index between the two methods. The pXRF was reliable in determining As, Ba, Ca, Cu, Mn, Pb, and Zn in impacted communities. Therefore, the pXRF can be a cost-effective alternative to using ICP-MS techniques to screen soil samples for several environmentally relevant contaminants to protect environmental public health.
environmental sciences