Abstract:Laser Thomson scattering (LTS) is a measurement technique that can determine electron velocity distribution functions in plasma systems. However, accurately inferring quantities of interest from an LTS signal requires the selection of a plasma physics submodel, and comprehensive uncertainty quantification (UQ) is needed to interpret the results. Automated model selection, parameter estimation, and UQ are particularly challenging for low-density, low-temperature, potentially non-Maxwellian plasmas like those created in space electric propulsion devices. This paper applies Bayesian inference and model selection to a Raman-calibrated LTS diagnostic in the context of such plasmas. Synthetic data are used to explore the performance of the method across signal-to-noise ratios and model fidelity regimes. Plasmas with Maxwellian and non-Maxwellian velocity distributions are well characterized using priors that span a range of accuracy and specificity. The model selection framework is shown to accurately detect the type of plasmas generating the electron velocity distribution submodel for signal-to-noise ratios greater than around 5. In addition, the Bayesian framework validates the widespread use of 95% confidence intervals from least-squares inversion as a conservative estimate of the uncertainty bounds. However, epistemic posterior correlations between the variables diverge between least-squares and Bayesian estimates as the number of variable parameters increases. This divergence demonstrates the need for Bayesian inference in cases where accurate correlations between electron parameters are necessary. Bayesian model selection is then applied to experimental Thomson scattering data collected in a nanosecond pulsed plasma, generated with a discharge voltage of 5 and 10 kV at a neutral argon background pressure of 7 Torr-Ar. The Bayesian maximum a posteriori estimates of the electron temperature and number density are 1.98 and 2.38 eV and 2.6 × 1018 and 2.72 × 1018 m−3, using the Maxwellian and Druyvesteyn submodels, respectively. Furthermore, for this dataset, the model selection criterion indicates strong support for the Maxwellian distribution at 10 kV discharge voltage and no strong preference between Maxwellian and Druyvesteyn distributions at 5 kV. The logarithmic Bayes’ factors for these cases are −35.76 and 1.07, respectively.

Automated Estimation of Plasma Temperature and Density from Emission Spectroscopy

Automated Bayesian high-throughput estimation of plasma temperature and density from emission spectroscopy

Plasma electron density profile tomography for EAST based on integrated data analysis

OES diagnostics of atmospheric pressure argon plasma: Electron temperature and density assessment through visible bremsstrahlung inversion method and collisional-radiative model

Integrated Data Analysis on the Electron Temperature Profile of HL-2A with the Bayesian Probability Inference Method

Statistical data analysis of x-ray spectroscopy data enabled by neural network accelerated Bayesian inference

Bayesian plasma model selection for Thomson scattering

Electron density and temperature measurement by continuum radiation emitted from weakly ionized atmospheric pressure plasmas

Determination of Non-Maxwellian Electron Energy Distributions in Low-Pressure Plasmas by Using the Optical Emission Spectroscopy and A Collisional-Radiative Model

Quantitative analysis of optical emission spectroscopy for plasma process monitoring

Calibration-free Optical Emission Spectroscopy Method for the Measurements of Gas Temperature and OH Density

A novel plasma optical emission spectroscopy method with neural network model for improving the accuracy of plasma diagnostics in low-temperature xenon plasma

Accelerated Bayesian inference of plasma profiles with self-consistent MHD equilibria at W7-X via neural networks

Stochastic determination of thermal reaction rate coefficients for air plasmas

Spectroscopic Measurement of Atmospheric-pressure Non-equilibrium Ar Plasma Using Continuum and Line Spectra

Temperature and Absolute Oh Density Measurement by the Relative Emission Spectroscopy in Diffuse Atmospheric-Pressure RF Glow Discharges

Optical Emission Spectroscopy As A Diagnostic for Plasmas in Liquids: Opportunities and Pitfalls

High-resolution Particle Density Measurement for Argon Plasma Plume by Image Reconstruction and Collisional-Radiative Model

Real-Time Diagnosis of Plasma Molecular Temperature Based on OES and Elastic-Net Regression Analysis

Integrated Data Analysis on the Electron Density Profile of HL-2A with the Bayesian Probability Inference Method