Joel Yeo,Benedikt J. Daurer,Dari Kimanius,Deepan Balakrishnan,Tristan Bepler,Yong Zi Tan,N. Duane Loh
Abstract:Ewald sphere curvature correction, which extends beyond the projection approximation, stretches the shallow depth of field in cryo-EM reconstructions of thick particles. Here we show that even for previously assumed thin particles, reconstruction artifacts which we refer to as ghosts can appear. By retrieving the lost phases of the electron exitwaves and accounting for the first Born approximation scattering within the particle, we show that these ghosts can be effectively eliminated. Our simulations demonstrate how such ghostbusting can improve reconstructions as compared to existing state-of-the-art software. Like ptychographic cryo-EM, our Ghostbuster algorithm uses phase retrieval to improve reconstructions, but unlike the former, we do not need to modify the existing data acquisition pipelines.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper attempts to address the issue of the shallower Depth of Field (DOF) caused by increased sample thickness in Single Particle Reconstruction (SPR) in cryo-Electron Microscopy (cryo-EM). Specifically, when using the traditional Projection Approximation (PA) for reconstruction, even for particles considered relatively thin, so-called "ghost" artifacts can appear. These artifacts severely affect the quality and resolution of the reconstruction.
### Background of the Problem
1. **Shallower Depth of Field**: As the resolution of cryo-EM improves, the depth of field of the microscope becomes shallower, leading to severe artifacts when reconstructing thick samples.
2. **Insufficiency of Projection Approximation**: The traditional projection approximation method assumes that the sample is infinitely thin, ignoring the diffraction physical effects within the sample, resulting in "ghost" artifacts in the reconstruction results.
3. **Phase Loss**: During cryo-EM imaging, the detector can only capture the intensity information of the complex hologram, while the phase information is lost, making it difficult to recover the original complex exit wave.
### Solution
The paper proposes an algorithm called "Ghostbuster," which addresses the above issues through the following steps:
1. **Phase Recovery**: Using the Reweighted Amplitude Flow (RAF) algorithm to recover the phase information of the 2D complex exit wave from real-valued images.
2. **Diffraction Tomography**: Using the Depth of Field Stretching (DOFS) algorithm, based on the First Born Approximation, to perform 3D reconstruction of the complex exit wave, thereby extending the depth of field and eliminating "ghost" artifacts.
### Main Contributions
1. **Improved Reconstruction Quality**: Through phase recovery and diffraction tomography, Ghostbuster can significantly improve the reconstruction quality of thick samples and reduce "ghost" artifacts.
2. **No Need to Modify Data Acquisition Process**: Unlike existing ptychographic cryo-EM methods, Ghostbuster does not require modifications to the existing data acquisition process, offering better practicality and compatibility.
3. **Theoretical Analysis**: The paper provides a detailed analysis of the relationship between depth of field and resolution and proposes a new resolution standard, providing a theoretical foundation for future research.
### Experimental Validation
The paper conducts numerical experiments using multi-slice simulated data to verify the effectiveness of the DOFS and Ghostbuster algorithms. The experimental results show that compared to existing methods, Ghostbuster can achieve higher quality 3D reconstructions at higher resolutions, especially when dealing with thick samples.
In summary, this paper proposes a new algorithmic framework that effectively addresses the issues of shallower depth of field and "ghost" artifacts in the reconstruction of thick samples in cryo-EM, providing new tools and technical support for high-resolution cryo-EM research.