Low-dose cryo-electron ptychography of proteins at sub-nanometer resolution

Berk Kucukoglu,Inayathulla Mohammed,Ricardo C. Guerrero-Ferreira,Massimo Kube,Julika Radecke,Stephanie Ribet,Georgios Varnavides,Max Leo Leidl,Kelvin Lau,Sergey Nazarov,Alexander Myasnikov,Carsten Sachse,Knut Mueller-Caspary,Colin Ophus,Henning Stahlberg
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.02.12.579607
2024-05-26
Abstract:Cryo-transmission electron microscopy (cryo-EM) of frozen hydrated specimens is an efficient method for the structural analysis of purified biological molecules. However, cryo-EM and cryo-electron tomography are limited by the low signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) of recorded images, making detection of smaller particles challenging. For dose-resilient samples often studied in the physical sciences, electron ptychography – a coherent diffractive imaging technique using 4D scanning transmission electron microscopy (4D-STEM) – has recently demonstrated excellent SNR and resolution down to tens of picometers for thin specimens imaged at room temperature. Here we applied 4D-STEM and ptychographic data analysis to frozen hydrated proteins, reaching sub-nanometer resolution 3D reconstructions. We employed low-dose cryo-EM with an aberration-corrected, convergent electron beam to collect 4D-STEM data for our reconstructions. The high frame rate of the electron detector allowed us to record large datasets of electron diffraction patterns with substantial overlaps between the interaction volumes of adjacent scan positions, from which the scattering potentials of the samples were iteratively reconstructed. The reconstructed micrographs show strong SNR enabling the reconstruction of the structure of apoferritin protein at up to 5.8 Å resolution. We also show structural analysis of the Phi92 capsid and sheath, tobacco mosaic virus, and bacteriorhodopsin at slightly lower resolutions.
Biophysics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper mainly aims to address the following issues: ### Main Research Problems 1. **Improving Resolution and Signal-to-Noise Ratio**: Traditional cryo-electron microscopy (cryo-EM) techniques are limited by low signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) when analyzing biomolecules such as proteins, making it difficult to detect smaller particles. The authors attempt to improve image resolution and SNR through cryo-electron ptychography. 2. **Expanding Applicability**: Traditional cryo-EM techniques usually struggle to achieve high-resolution analysis of proteins smaller than 50 kDa. This paper attempts to achieve high-resolution imaging of smaller protein particles by using 4D scanning transmission electron microscopy (4D-STEM) combined with ptychographic data processing methods. ### Specific Technical Challenges and Solutions 1. **Signal Acquisition and Processing**: For cryo-hydrated samples, data is collected using 4D-STEM technology, and iterative reconstruction algorithms (such as difference map computation, extended ptychographic iterative engine, etc.) are used to reconstruct the scattering potential of the sample from the recorded diffraction patterns. 2. **Low-Dose Imaging**: To reduce electron beam damage to the sample, low-dose cryo-EM imaging is employed. Fast electron detectors allow the collection of a large number of electron diffraction patterns with overlapping interaction volumes, enabling iterative reconstruction of the sample's scattering potential from these patterns. 3. **Automated Workflow**: An automated data acquisition and processing workflow was developed, including the use of Python scripts to control 4D-STEM data acquisition and the use of py4DSTEM software for real-time monitoring and offline computation. ### Core Results - Through cryo-electron ptychography, sub-nanometer 3D reconstruction was successfully achieved, reaching a resolution of 5.8 Å for the apo-ferritin protein. - Structural analysis was also performed on samples such as the phi92 bacteriophage tail protein and tobacco mosaic virus (TMV). Although the resolution was slightly lower, the effectiveness of the technique was still demonstrated. - The study also explored the potential application of this technique to bacteriorhodopsin 2D crystals, further validating its potential for biological samples. ### Discussion and Future Prospects - Despite the significant progress made with current technology, there are still some technical challenges to overcome, such as dose fractionation, scanning precision optimization, and data processing speed improvement. - It is anticipated that with further technological advancements, this method will be applicable to higher resolution structural analysis, especially showing great potential in the 3D reconstruction of cellular and tissue samples.