Abstract:In a typical decentralized autonomous organization (DAO), people organize themselves into a group that is programmatically managed. DAOs can act as bidders in auctions, with a DAO's bid treated by the auctioneer as if it had been submitted by an individual, without regard to the internal structure of the DAO. We study auctions in which the bidders are DAOs. More precisely, we consider the design of two-level auctions in which the "participants" are groups of bidders rather than individuals. Bidders form DAOs to pool resources, but must then also negotiate the terms by which the DAO's winnings are shared. We model the outcome of a DAO's negotiations by an aggregation function (which aggregates DAO members' bids into a single group bid), and a budget-balanced cost-sharing mechanism (that determines DAO members' access to the DAO's allocation and distributes the total payment demanded from the DAO to its members). We pursue two-level mechanisms that are incentive-compatible (with truthful bidding a dominant strategy for members of each DAO) and approximately welfare-optimal. We prove that, even in the case of a single-item auction, incentive-compatible welfare maximization is not possible: No matter what the outer mechanism and the cost-sharing mechanisms used by DAOs, the welfare of the resulting two-level mechanism can be a $\approx \ln n$ factor less than optimal. We complement this lower bound with a natural two-level mechanism that achieves a matching approximate welfare guarantee. Our upper bound also extends to multi-item auctions where individuals have additive valuations. Finally, we show that our positive results cannot be extended much further: Even in multi-item settings with unit-demand bidders, truthful two-level mechanisms form a highly restricted class and as a consequence cannot guarantee any non-trivial approximation of the maximum social welfare.

Nash Equilibria of Two-round Auctions

Strategic behavior in dynamic auctions

I Want to Tell You? Maximizing Revenue in First-Price Two-Stage Auctions

Dominant-Strategy Versus Bayesian Multi-item Auctions

Approximately Efficient Two-Sided Combinatorial Auctions

When Bidders Are DAOs

Budget-Constrained Auctions with Unassured Priors: Strategic Equivalence and Structural Properties

Auctioning with Strategically Reticent Bidders

An N-to-1 Bidder Reduction for Multi-item Auctions and Its Applications

Double Auction In Two-Level Markets

Bidding Strategy for Auctions with Stochastic Upper Limit

Advertising a second-price auction

Bayesian auctions with efficient queries

Auctions with synergy and resale

Decomposing Truthful and Competitive Online Double Auctions

Efficient Auctions with Identity-Dependent Negative Externalities.

Optimal Auctions for Partially Rational Bidders.

Equilibria and incentives for illiquid auction markets

Incentive-Compatible Diffusion Auctions

Boundedly Rational Agents in Sequential Posted Pricing

The Non-Existence of Equilibrium in Sequential Auctions when Bids Are Revealed