Abstract:The aim of the work presented in this paper is to develop and evaluate an integrated system that provides automated lecture style evaluation, allowing teachers to get instant feedback related to the goodness of their lecturing style. The proposed system aims to promote improvement of lecture quality, that could upgrade the overall student learning experience. The proposed application utilizes specific measurable biometric characteristics, such as facial expressions, body activity, speech rate and intonation, hand movement, and facial pose, extracted from a video showing the lecturer from the audience point of view. Measurable biometric features extracted during a lecture are combined to provide teachers with a score reflecting lecture style quality both at frame rate and by providing lecture quality metrics for the whole lecture. The acceptance of the proposed lecture style evaluation system was evaluated by chief education officers, teachers and students regarding the functionality, usefulness of the application, and possible improvements. The results indicate that participants found the application novel and useful in providing automated feedback regarding lecture quality. Furthermore, the performance evaluation of the proposed system was compared with the performance of humans in the task of lecture style evaluation. Results indicate that the proposed system not only achieves similar performance to human observers, but in some cases, it outperforms them.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### Problems the Paper Aims to Solve
The paper aims to develop and evaluate an integrated system for the automatic assessment of lecture styles, enabling teachers to receive instant feedback on the strengths and weaknesses of their lecture styles. Specifically, the system provides feedback by extracting specific measurable biometric features from videos (such as facial expressions, body movements, speech rate and tone, gestures, and facial postures) to enhance lecture quality, ultimately improving the student learning experience.
### Main Contributions
1. **Defining Lecture Style Quality Features Using Human Expertise**: Through literature review and interviews with stakeholders, a set of biometric features associated with high-quality lecture styles was defined.
2. **Using an Extended Set of Lecture Style Quality Features**: More comprehensive features were considered, including facial postures, activity-related indicators, tone, word density, and gestures.
3. **Performance Evaluation and Comparison with Human Performance**: The proposed system was evaluated for performance and compared with human performance in the task of assessing lecture styles.
### Method Overview
1. **Defining Lecture Quality Indicators**: Through literature review and interviews with education officials, teachers, and students, a set of features for high-quality and low-quality lecture styles was defined.
2. **Feature Extraction**: Using computer vision and speech recognition technologies, biometric features such as facial expressions, body movements, speech rate, and tone were extracted from videos.
3. **Lecture Quality Score Estimation**: Combining the extracted features, a lecture quality score for each frame was calculated, providing an overall measure of lecture quality.
4. **Performance Evaluation**: The system's performance was validated by comparing it with human assessment results.
### Conclusion
The research results indicate that participants found the application novel and useful, capable of providing automated feedback on lecture quality. Additionally, the system not only achieved performance comparable to human observers in some cases but even exceeded human performance in certain situations.