Abstract:Recently we have shown that the anti-Pfaffian state and a state described by the second Landau level (SLL) projection of antiholomorphic Pfaffian wavefunctions have large overlap and almost identical low-energy orbital entanglement structures, suggesting they have the same topological order. In this paper, we further show that the similar entanglement structure observed in the SLL projected state is also identifiable in other Landau level projected states, indicating it is not the result of the SLL projection but rather a "fingerprint" of the PH-Pfaffian topological order of the original unprojected antiholomorphic Pfaffian wavefunctions. Consequently, we argue that the SLL projected state, and therefore the anti-Pfaffian state, is a PH-Pfaffian topological order state. We also discuss the implications on the edge physics.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem this paper attempts to address is determining whether the anti-Pfaffian state belongs to the PH-Pfaffian topological order. Specifically, the authors explore the relationship between the SLL (second Landau level) projected state and the anti-Pfaffian state by studying the entanglement spectrum structure under different Landau level projections to determine if they share the same topological order. ### Background - **ν=5/2 Fractional Quantum Hall Effect (FQHE)**: The ground state candidates for this system include the Pfaffian state, the anti-Pfaffian state, and the PH-Pfaffian state. - **Pfaffian and anti-Pfaffian states**: These two states are particle-hole symmetric but lack the symmetry of the PH-Pfaffian state. - **PH-Pfaffian state**: It has a unique edge structure that supports downstream charged boson modes and upstream neutral Majorana fermion modes, consistent with experimental results. ### Research Methods 1. **SLL Projection**: The authors propose using the SLL projection operator instead of the LLL projection operator to generate the SPH-Pfaffian state. 2. **Entanglement Spectrum Analysis**: By calculating the orbital entanglement spectrum under different Landau level projections, the authors compare the low-energy entanglement spectrum structures of these states. ### Main Findings - **Similar Entanglement Spectrum Structure**: Under the SLL projection, the anti-Pfaffian state and the SPH-Pfaffian state exhibit almost identical low-energy entanglement spectrum structures. - **Other Landau Level Projections**: Similar low-energy entanglement spectrum structures are observed under other Landau level projections, indicating that this structure is not a result of the SLL projection but rather a "fingerprint" of the original unprojected anti-holomorphic Pfaffian wave function. ### Conclusion - **Topological Order of the Anti-Pfaffian State**: Based on numerical results, the authors believe that the SLL projection does not alter the PH-Pfaffian topological order of the original unprojected anti-holomorphic Pfaffian wave function. Therefore, the SLL projected state is a PH-Pfaffian topological order state, and the anti-Pfaffian state is also a PH-Pfaffian topological order state, despite lacking PH symmetry. - **Edge Structure**: As a PH-Pfaffian topological order state, the anti-Pfaffian state has a PH-Pfaffian edge structure consisting of a single edge, supporting downstream charged boson modes and upstream neutral Majorana modes. Additionally, the anti-Pfaffian state can be viewed as a hole-Pfaffian state embedded in the ν=1 integer quantum Hall state, with a standard anti-Pfaffian edge structure consisting of two edges. ### Significance - **Experimental Verification**: The PH-Pfaffian edge structure is consistent with experimental results, further supporting the possibility of the anti-Pfaffian state as the ground state of the ν=5/2 FQHE. - **Theoretical Advancement**: This study provides a new perspective for understanding topological order in the fractional quantum Hall effect, contributing to the theoretical development in this field.

Is the Anti-Pfaffian a PH-Pfaffian Topological Order State?

PH-Pfaffian order in a translationally and rotationally invariant system

Fingerprints of anti-Pfaffian topological order in quantum point contact transport

A Compressed Particle-Hole Symmetric Pfaffian State for $ν= 5/2$ Quantum Hall Effect

A Hafnian PH-Pfaffian State for 5/2 Quantum Hall Effect

Fractional Quantum Hall Bilayers at Half-Filling: Tunneling-driven Non-Abelian Phase

A ug 2 01 6 Fractional Quantum Hall Bilayers at Half-Filling : Tunneli ng-driven Non-Abelian Phase

Chiral projected entangled-pair state with topological order

Striped Quantum Hall State in A Half-filled Landau Level

From Fractional Chern Insulators To Abelian And Non-Abelian Fractional Quantum Hall States: Adiabatic Continuity And Orbital Entanglement Spectrum

Competing ν = 5/2 fractional quantum Hall states in confined geometry.

Topological states on fractal lattices

Identifying Non-Abelian Topological Ordered State and Transition by Momentum Polarization

Experimental constraints and a possible quantum Hall state at $ν=5/2$

Discovery of Competing 5/2 Fractional Quantum Hall States

Noncommutative pfaffians and classification of states of five-dimensional quasi-spin

Competing Nu=5/2 Fractional Quantum Hall States In Confined Geometry

Topological phase transition between Jain states and daughter states of the ν = 1/2 fractional quantum Hall state

Topological phase transition between composite-fermion and Pfaffian daughter states near ν = 1/2 FQHS

(SPT-)LSM theorems from projective non-invertible symmetries

Towards a classification of mixed-state topological orders in two dimensions