Abstract:Cultural values vary significantly around the world. Despite a large heterogeneity, similarities across national cultures are present. This paper studies cross-country culture heterogeneity via the joint inference of country-specific copula graphical models from world-wide survey data. To this end, a random graph generative model of the cultural networks is introduced, with a latent space and proximity measures that embed cultural relatedness across countries. Within-country heterogeneity is also accounted for, via parametric modelling of the marginal distributions of each cultural trait. All together, the different components of the model are able to identify several dimensions of culture.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper aims to address the issue of cross - national cultural heterogeneity. Specifically, researchers attempt to study the cultural heterogeneity between different countries by jointly inferring country - specific cultural network models, while taking into account the cultural heterogeneity within countries. To achieve this goal, the paper introduces a random graph generation model, which includes a latent space and a method for measuring cultural relevance. In addition, the paper also considers the heterogeneity within countries by parameterizing the marginal distribution of each cultural feature. Different components of the entire model can identify multiple dimensions of culture. The paper mainly focuses on three statistical challenges: 1. **Population Heterogeneity**: The respondent groups in survey questionnaires are usually heterogeneous. If a certain characteristic of respondents (such as gender) has an impact on their cultural views, the marginal distribution of specific cultural characteristics may vary by gender. Therefore, statistical adjustments are required to avoid introducing biases in subsequent analyses. The paper addresses this problem by using a parametric regression model within the Gaussian Copula graphical modeling framework, in particular, using an ordered regression model to link responses to specific survey questions with respondent characteristics (such as age and gender). 2. **Structural Similarity of Cultural Networks**: Some structural similarities are expected to exist between the cultural networks of different countries. For example, tolerance for abortion and homosexuality are strongly and positively associated in all countries. This information should be embedded in the model to better quantify the similarities and heterogeneities between countries. To this end, the paper proposes a random graph model for the joint distribution of conditional independence graphs related to the Gaussian Copula graphical model of each country. This model is defined by a latent space, allowing the identification of correlations at the structural level between different countries. The proximity of countries in this space (inferred from the data) is associated with the structural similarity between cultural networks. 3. **Explaining Cultural Heterogeneity**: In addition to assessing the degree of cross - national cultural heterogeneity, the paper also attempts to explain the reasons for this heterogeneity. To this end, the proposed random graph model adds factors that may drive cultural heterogeneity, such as geographical distance and historical - linguistic connections. These factors are expected to play a crucial role in explaining the position of countries in the cultural spectrum, which is consistent with their roles in social, political, and economic studies. In summary, by integrating multiple data sources and statistical models, this paper aims to gain a deeper understanding of cultural differences between countries and the reasons behind them.

Joint modelling of national cultures accounting for within and between-country heterogeneity

Cultures as networks of cultural traits: A unifying framework for measuring culture and cultural distances

Advancing our understanding of cultural heterogeneity with unsupervised machine learning

Copula Graphical Models for Heterogeneous Mixed Data

Bayesian Nonparametric Modelling of Conditional Multidimensional Dependence Structures

Reconciling long-term cultural diversity and short-term collective social behavior

Joint estimation of multiple high-dimensional Gaussian copula graphical models

Joint modelling of longitudinal measurements and survival times via a multivariate copula approach

Modelling heterogeneity in Latent Space Models for Multidimensional Networks

Extracting hierarchical features of cultural variation using network-based clustering

Joint Latent Space Model for Social Networks with Multivariate Attributes

Modelling Correlation Matrices in Multivariate Dyadic Data: Latent Variable Models for Intergenerational Exchanges of Family Support

How Culture Evolves: Measuring Cultural Distance and Variation

Modeling, dependence, classification, united statistical science, many cultures

Correlation between Multivariate Datasets, from Inter-Graph Distance computed using Graphical Models Learnt With Uncertainties

Emerging Heterogeneities in Italian Customs and Comparison with Nearby Countries

Modeling society with statistical mechanics: an application to cultural contact and immigration

Dimensions and Dynamics of National Culture: Synthesizing Hofstede With Inglehart

Joint modelling of non-crossing additive quantile regression via constrained B-spline varying coefficients

Quantitative Analysis of Cultural Dynamics Seen from an Event-based Social Network