Cultures as networks of cultural traits: A unifying framework for measuring culture and cultural distances

Luca De Benedictis,Roberto Rondinelli,Veronica Vinciotti

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/jrsssa/qnac007

2022-09-16

Abstract:Making use of the information from the World Value Survey (WVS), and operationalizing a definition of national culture that encompasses both the relevance of specific cultural traits and the interdependence among them, this paper proposes a methodology to reveal the latent structure of national culture and to measure cultural distance between countries that takes into account both the difference in cultural traits and the difference in the network structure of national cultures. Exploiting the possibilities offered by copula graphical models for discrete data, this paper infers the cultural networks of all the countries included in the WVS (Wave 6) and proposes a novel unifying framework to measure national culture and international cultural distances. The Jeffreys' divergence between copula graphical models, taken as the measure of cultural distance between countries, captures the orthogonality of the two components of cultural distance: the one based on cultural traits and the one based on the network structure among them. Moreover, the two components are shown to correlate with different national and structural characteristics of cultural networks, thus encompassing the different informational sets related to national cultures.

Applications,Physics and Society

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper attempts to address the issue of how to define and quantify national culture and measure cultural distance between different countries. Specifically, the authors propose a new framework that utilizes data from the World Values Survey (WVS), considering not only the importance of specific cultural traits but also the interdependencies between these traits, thereby revealing the underlying structure of national culture and measuring cultural distance.

### Main Issues
1. **Defining National Culture**: There is a lack of consensus in existing research on the definition of national culture, especially in terms of how to comprehensively consider cultural traits and their interrelationships.
2. **Measuring Cultural Distance**: Traditional methods mainly focus on the differences in individual cultural traits, neglecting the differences in the network structure of these traits, which may lead to measurement bias.

### Solutions
1. **Network Structure of Cultural Traits**: The authors hypothesize that national culture is not merely a simple sum of cultural traits but a network structure composed of these traits and their interdependencies.
2. **New Measurement Framework**: Using graphical models (specifically copula graphical models) to infer the cultural network of each country, the authors propose a new cultural distance index—Jeffreys’ divergence (JD index), which includes two orthogonal components: differences based on cultural traits (JD marginals) and differences based on the network structure of traits (JD network).

### Methods
- **Data Source**: Using data from the 6th wave of WVS (2010-2014), covering 60 countries.
- **Selection of Cultural Traits**: 10 cultural traits were selected, such as happiness, trust, respect for authority, willingness to express opinions, importance of religious beliefs, acceptance of homosexuality and abortion, national pride, post-materialist tendencies, obedience, and independence.
- **Graphical Models**: Using copula graphical models to infer the cultural network structure of each country.
- **Measuring Cultural Distance**: Measuring cultural distance by calculating the Jeffreys’ divergence between the cultural networks of two countries.

### Results
- **Network Structure of Cultural Traits**: Demonstrated the complex interdependencies between cultural traits in different countries.
- **New Perspective on Cultural Distance**: The JD index considers not only the differences in cultural traits but also the differences in the network structure of these traits, providing a more comprehensive method for measuring cultural distance.
- **Empirical Analysis**: Through bivariate regression analysis, the main factors influencing cultural distance between countries were revealed.

### Significance
- **Theoretical Contribution**: Proposed a new framework for measuring cultural distance, emphasizing the importance of the network structure of cultural traits.
- **Practical Value**: Provides more accurate information on national cultural heterogeneity for academia and public policy makers, aiding in the understanding of the uniqueness, similarities, and diversity of societies in different countries.