Abstract:At the peak of the tech bubble, only 0.57% of market valuation comes from dividends in the next year. Taking the ratio of total market value to the value of one-year dividends, we obtain a valuation-based duration of 175 years. In contrast, at the height of the global financial crisis, more than 2.2% of market value is from dividends in the next year, implying a duration of 46 years. What drives valuation duration? We find that market participants have limited information about cash flow beyond one year. Therefore, an increase in valuation duration is due to a decrease in the discount rate rather than good news about long-term growth. Accordingly, valuation duration negatively predicts annual market return with an out-of-sample R2 of 15%, robustly outperforming other predictors in the literature. While the price-dividend ratio reflects the overall valuation level, our valuation-based measure of duration captures the slope of the valuation term structure. We show that valuation duration, as a discount rate proxy, is a critical state variable that augments the price-dividend ratio in spanning the (latent) state space for stock-market dynamics.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper explores the issue of the valuation horizon in stock markets. During the peak of the technology bubble, only 0.57% of the stock market valuation came from dividends in the next year, which means that the majority of the value came from cash flows in the more distant future, resulting in a valuation horizon of 175 years. However, during the trough of the global financial crisis, over 2.2% of the market value came from dividends in the next year, leading to a lowered valuation horizon of 46 years. The study found that changes in the valuation horizon are mainly driven by discount rates rather than long-term positive news, and it is negatively correlated with annual market returns, with a predictive ability of 15%, surpassing other forecasting indicators.
By analyzing prices of dividend strips with different maturity dates, the author identifies that the market state space is composed of two key variables: the valuation horizon and the price-dividend ratio. These two variables provide sufficient information for predicting future returns and dividend growth. The valuation horizon, as a proxy for discount rates, is closely related to expected returns because of the significant difference in predictability between short-term and long-term cash flows. The research shows that the valuation horizon has a stronger predictive power for returns compared to the price-dividend ratio and other valuation indicators, and is not affected by common error adjustment methods.
The main contribution of this paper lies in identifying the two key state variables in the stock market: the valuation horizon and the price-dividend ratio, which fully describe market dynamics and reveal changes in discount rates. Additionally, it emphasizes the limited information that the market has about future cash flow growth expectations, which explains the strong correlation between the valuation horizon and return prediction indicators.