Abstract:A conjecture of Shumakovitch states that every nontrivial knot has 2-torsion in its Khovanov homology. We show that if a knot $K$ has no 2-torsion in its Khovanov homology, then the rank of its reduced Khovanov homology is minimal among all knots obtainable from $K$ by a proper rational tangle replacement. It follows, for example, that unknotting number 1 knots have 2-torsion in their Khovanov homology.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper is primarily dedicated to addressing a problem in knot theory within mathematics, specifically focusing on the question of whether there exists 2-torsion in Khovanov homology. Shumakovitch's conjecture posits that every non-trivial knot contains 2-torsion elements in its Khovanov homology. The authors of this paper provide topological evidence for Shumakovitch's conjecture by proving that if a knot $ K $ has no 2-torsion in its Khovanov homology, then the rank of its reduced Khovanov homology is minimal among all knots obtained from $ K $ by appropriate rational tangle replacements. They also verify that this conjecture holds for a broad category of knots, including all knots with an unknotting number of 1. Additionally, the paper proves a corollary that any knot with an unknotting number of 1 must have 2-torsion in its Khovanov homology. More broadly, if a non-trivial knot $ K $ can be obtained from an unknot or a trefoil knot by appropriate rational tangle replacements, then $ K $ must also contain 2-torsion in its Khovanov homology. These results not only provide new perspectives on understanding the properties of Khovanov homology but also offer a pathway for verifying Shumakovitch's conjecture.

A minimality property for knots without Khovanov 2-torsion